The core value of department stores like Saks was curating multiple luxury brands in one place. However, with brands like Louis Vuitton building their own flagship stores and generating 95% of sales directly, they have bypassed the middleman. This direct access to consumers makes the traditional department store model obsolete.
Related Insights
The company never proactively pitched major retailers. Instead, they focused on creating a powerful digital presence and a superior product. This strategy made the brand so desirable that major players like Sephora initiated the partnership, flipping the traditional wholesale sales dynamic.
Numi initially used a wholesale model but found it ineffective. They were relying on third-party retail staff to explain a new product category and address the social stigma around sweating. Shifting to direct-to-consumer (DTC) allowed them to control the narrative, educate customers directly, and grow 300%.
While many celebrity brands hit a valuation ceiling around $1 billion, Skims has broken through by aggressively pursuing a multi-channel strategy. Expanding into a significant number of physical retail stores is the crucial step that elevates a personality-driven brand into a durable, multi-billion-dollar enterprise.
Large CPG players have slow, agency-driven feedback loops. Nimble DTC brands can win by rapidly testing creative, messaging, and offers online, gaining an insurmountable learning advantage. Speed itself becomes the strategic edge, not just a byproduct of being small.
The online trend of consumers seeking affordable "dupes" of expensive products will translate into a new brick-and-mortar retail concept. These stores will offer lower-priced alternatives to name-brand goods across fashion and electronics, applying the successful private-label model of Trader Joe's to a full department store format.
Large retailers are moving toward having effectively the same massive product catalogs via marketplaces. As selection becomes commoditized and ceases to be a differentiator, retailers will be forced to compete on the next level: deeply personalized service and unique customer experiences.
A few dominant consumer platforms are capturing the majority of retail sales, creating a winner-take-all market. These companies leverage their scale and cash flow to reinvest in technology and advertising, widening their competitive moats much like the largest tech companies.
Focusing solely on direct-to-consumer (DTC) or wholesale is a failed strategy. Nike's retreat from wholesale and Allbirds' late entry into physical retail both backfired. A balanced, multi-channel presence is now a non-negotiable for consumer brands to meet customer expectations.
The rise of livestream shopping presents a cultural challenge for luxury brands built on exclusivity and "gatekeeping." This new, transparent sales channel forces them to reconcile their closed-off heritage with the open, interactive expectations of the next generation of buyers.
To combat the perception that department stores are dated, Macy's CEO suggests reframing the model as a "marketplace." This modern term highlights its core strengths: a wide selection of categories, brands, and price points serving multiple generations across both physical and digital channels, positioning it as a future-proof concept.
