Large retailers are moving toward having effectively the same massive product catalogs via marketplaces. As selection becomes commoditized and ceases to be a differentiator, retailers will be forced to compete on the next level: deeply personalized service and unique customer experiences.
Related Insights
As buyers increasingly use AI as a research partner, the uniquely human aspects of a brand—trust, relationship, and service—become the most critical competitive advantage. When AI can compare features and pricing, the human experience is what will ultimately sway the decision.
As AI tools become ubiquitous, customer expectations will shift. Receiving an irrelevant ad or email will no longer be a minor annoyance but a signal that the brand is technologically inept. Personalization is evolving from a competitive advantage to a basic requirement for brand credibility.
While AI fragments shopping channels, it also enables hyper-personalization of the fulfillment experience. By integrating external data like weather, transit times, and regional issues, brands can proactively communicate with customers about their orders, creating a deeper, more valuable connection.
To survive the threat of AI commoditizing services, businesses must build a strong brand. The goal is for customers to ask for your company by name (e.g., "Alexa, send me a Pizza Hut") rather than a generic request ("send me a pizza"), making you a destination, not an option.
As return volumes rise, brands that make the process effortless and predictable will earn loyalty that can't be bought. This frictionless experience during a period of high customer anxiety builds a durable competitive moat. Every return also generates compounding data advantages for future forecasting and merchandising, further widening the gap.
As AI commoditizes technology, traditional moats are eroding. The only sustainable advantage is "relationship capital"—being defined by *who* you serve, not *what* you do. This is built through depth (feeling seen), density (community belonging), and durability (permission to offer more products).
For product categories where AI can easily replicate the core technology (like online file converters or headshot generators), defensibility shifts away from tech. The business becomes a pure play on marketing, distribution, and brand, much like succeeding with a new brand of canned water.
In a marketplace with endless options, product features are table stakes. The deciding factor for buyers is now the total experience. Salespeople have lost control of the buying cycle and must now influence it by delivering exceptional service and building trust from the first interaction.
As AI commoditizes basic functionality, 'good enough' is no longer sufficient and will be considered mediocre. Sustainable advantage will come from the top of the stack: superior design, craft, brand, point of view, and storytelling.
As AI makes it incredibly easy to build products, the market will be flooded with options. The critical, differentiating skill will no longer be technical execution but human judgment: deciding *what* should exist, which features matter, and the right distribution strategy. Synthesizing these elements is where future value lies.
