We scan new podcasts and send you the top 5 insights daily.
While NATO has improved at fast attribution, system recovery, and maritime monitoring, it lacks an effective deterrent strategy. Julianne Smith argues that treating hybrid attacks as isolated incidents on a case-by-case basis prevents the alliance from imposing meaningful consequences. Without aggregating these incidents into identifiable patterns of aggression that trigger collective allied retaliation, Russia receives a continuous signal that it can escalate hybrid operations without paying a price.
The next escalation in the Russia-NATO conflict won't be conventional warfare but an expansion of the current "shadow war." This involves asymmetric tactics like cyberattacks, destroying undersea cables, using drones in allied airspace, and funding vandalism of critical infrastructure to divide and destabilize European allies from within.
When Germany attributed explosive drones at Leipzig airport to the Russian state, Berlin chose not to invoke Article 4 emergency consultations at NATO, preferring to manage the incident bilaterally. Julianne Smith highlights that European allies' hesitance to activate alliance mechanisms—stemming partly from fears that the U.S. might dismiss Article 5 contingencies—risks signaling to Moscow that NATO members are afraid to test allied collective security in response to gray-zone aggression.
Russia sees itself as the weaker party against NATO and is deterred from a direct attack. The greater danger lies in miscalculation, misunderstandings, or incidents (like instability in Belarus or hybrid warfare) spiraling out of control.
The world is no longer in a simple state of war or peace. While kinetic warfare is obvious, Russia and other actors engage in hybrid warfare—cyber attacks, GPS jamming, sabotage. This constant, low-level conflict is harder to detect and define, blurring the lines.
Beyond historical objectives of weakening alliance cohesion and creating doubt around NATO's Article 5 commitment, Russia's recent hybrid escalation carries a direct tactical objective. Because the United States halted security assistance to Ukraine, European nations stepped up to fill the void. Julianne Smith explains that Moscow is intentionally carrying out hybrid attacks across Europe to demonstrate that continued military support for Ukraine comes with steep domestic risks and costs.
Julianne Smith notes Russian hybrid warfare has shifted dramatically from proxy operations reliant on plausible deniability to brazen, near-kinetic strikes, such as explosive-laden drones hitting Leipzig airport. Russia is no longer attempting to conceal responsibility, challenging the line between sub-threshold hybrid harassment and conventional kinetic warfare that could potentially trigger a NATO Article 5 collective defense response.
Paradoxically, by only hardening defenses and not retaliating against Russia's "grey zone" attacks, Europe fails to establish deterrence. This inaction may embolden Russia to continue escalating until a catastrophic miscalculation triggers a major conflict.
NATO's integrity is bifurcated. Its formal components—the military structure, institutions, and treaty—remain intact. However, its core function as a deterrent has been severely damaged because the US President has made the Article 5 commitment conditional. This undermines the perceived 'will' to defend allies, which is what truly deters adversaries like Russia.
Even when Russian drones or jets enter NATO airspace by "accident," it is not a mistake but a deliberate policy. Choosing to operate pilots and missile systems with a high tolerance for error is a form of calculated recklessness. This tactic applies constant pressure on Europe and signals a high-risk appetite without firing a shot.
Because NATO as an institution cannot implement economic sanctions or expel diplomats, meaningful cost imposition against Russia requires creative national enforcement paired with enhanced military authorities. Julianne Smith points to France boarding Russian shadow fleet vessels evading Baltic sanctions and Norway seizing a Russian vessel in Svalbard over Crimean damages. Expanding the Supreme Allied Commander Europe's pre-designated maritime authorities could transform these independent actions into coordinated, alliance-wide deterrence.