Asking someone in crisis if they need help can force them to admit vulnerability. A more powerful and kind approach is to anticipate their needs (e.g., money after an arrest) and provide help directly without being asked.

Related Insights

When people share a problem, their primary need is acknowledgment, not an immediate solution. Philosopher Kieran Setia explains that rushing to offer advice or reassurance can feel like a denial of their experience. True support begins with validating their struggle.

Experiments with a group exercise called the "reciprocity ring" revealed a universal truth: people are naturally willing to help. The primary obstacle to unlocking this generosity isn't convincing people to give; it's getting them to overcome their own reluctance to ask for what they need in the first place.

The common offer "Let me know if I can help" places the burden on an already decision-fatigued caregiver. To make it actionable, caregivers should pre-emptively create a list of simple, concrete tasks (e.g., picking up a prescription, driving to an appointment). This allows well-meaning friends to provide tangible support.

Money is a taboo subject often tied to shame, which paralyzes action. To give financial advice effectively to friends or family, frame the conversation as an act of love and concern, not judgment or superiority. This approach mirrors how we would address a physical ailment and makes the recipient more open to help.

During his cancer treatment, Steve Garrity learned that the most meaningful support came from friends who were simply present, even without conversation. One friend drove him to chemo during a fight, demonstrating that showing up is more powerful than finding the perfect words. This is a crucial lesson for leaders and colleagues supporting someone through hardship.

Instead of searching for the perfect words, which don't exist, it's more effective to be honest about your uncertainty. Simply say "I'm here for you" and then offer a practical, authentic act of support based on your own skills and passions, like cooking a meal or walking their dog.

The generic offer "let me know if I can help" rarely gets a response. Asking "What does support look like right now?" is a more effective, direct question. It gently shifts the burden to the other person to define their needs, making them more likely to accept help and reducing resentment.

When someone is upset, directly ask if they want to be "heard" (emotional support), "helped" (practical solutions), or "hugged" (social connection). This simple heuristic clarifies their needs and prevents the conversational mismatch of offering solutions when empathy is desired.

When a partner or friend shares a problem, resist the urge to immediately offer solutions. Instead, first ask, "Do you want to be helped, heard, or hugged?" This simple question clarifies their immediate emotional need and ensures you provide the right type of support, avoiding common communication breakdowns.

This common phrase, while well-intentioned, gives a grieving person a chore: they must identify a need and reach out. It makes the helper feel better without actually helping. Instead, proactively do the helpful thing you thought of—bring food, mow the lawn, run an errand. Unsolicited action is true support.