The fear of AI in music isn't that it will replace human artists, but that it will drown them out. The real danger is AI-generated music flooding streaming playlists, making genuine discovery impossible. The ultimate risk is platforms like Spotify creating their own AI music and feeding it directly into their algorithms, effectively cutting human artists out of the ecosystem entirely.

Related Insights

While AI tools once gave creators an edge, they now risk producing democratized, undifferentiated output. IBM's AI VP, who grew to 200k followers, now uses AI less. The new edge is spending more time on unique human thinking and using AI only for initial ideation, not final writing.

The song "Walk My Walk" by the AI artist "Breaking Rust" topped the Billboard country music chart. This event forces creative industries to confront how to classify and rank AI-generated content, sparking debate on whether AI art should compete directly against human-made work on established platforms.

After several iterations, the fortune-telling app started overusing the word "rock," generating similar fortunes about finding rocks that look like pizza or cupcakes. This highlights how generative AI can fixate on a theme, demonstrating the need for human testing and curation to ensure variety and quality.

As AI drives the cost of content creation to zero, the world floods with 'average' material. In this environment, the most valuable and scarce skill becomes 'taste'—the ability to identify, curate, and champion high-quality, commercially viable work. This elevates the role of human curators over pure creators.

True creative mastery emerges from an unpredictable human process. AI can generate options quickly but bypasses this journey, losing the potential for inexplicable, last-minute genius that defines truly great work. It optimizes for speed at the cost of brilliance.

Venture capitalists calling creators "Luddite snooty critics" for their concerns about AI-generated content creates a hostile dynamic that could turn the entire creative industry against AI labs and their investors, hindering adoption.

The success of "Breaking Rust," an AI-generated artist, on a Billboard chart suggests market acceptance of non-human creativity. This indicates that for many listeners, enjoyment is decoupled from the creator's identity, challenging traditional notions of artistry and revealing that audiences may not care about a song's origin as long as they like it.

As AI-generated content creates a sea of sameness, audiences will seek what machines cannot replicate: genuine emotion and deep, personal narrative. This will drive a creator-led shift toward more meaningful, long-form content that offers a real human connection.

The concept of data colonialism—extracting value from a population's data—is no longer limited to the Global South. It now applies to creative professionals in Western countries whose writing, music, and art are scraped without consent to build generative AI systems, concentrating wealth and power in the hands of a few tech firms.

The #1 country music song, 'Walk My Walk' by Breaking Rust, is believed to be AI-generated. Its mainstream success, with millions of streams and potential Grammy buzz, marks a critical milestone where AI is not just creating art but also achieving significant commercial success.