Get your free personalized podcast brief

We scan new podcasts and send you the top 5 insights daily.

To get coaches to respond to his DMs, founder Ali Khokhar added a simple P.S.: "I am also looking for a coach myself." This turned a cold pitch into a potential sales lead for them, increasing his reply rate from nearly zero to 60%.

Related Insights

The most common call-to-action—asking for a meeting—is the least effective. Instead of requesting time, provide value upfront with an offer-based CTA (e.g., sharing a tailored insight or audit). This simple shift can dramatically increase reply rates by framing the interaction around giving, not taking.

Generic cold outreach often fails. To achieve a higher response rate (e.g., 50%), identify and lead with a specific, tangible point of commonality. This could be a shared university, sports team, or niche interest, which makes the recipient far more receptive to helping a stranger.

When buyers are overwhelmed with outreach, a simple, value-driven LinkedIn message that shares social proof without a hard ask can break through. It positions the seller as a consultant rather than just another vendor demanding time, leading to higher engagement.

Instead of DMing a link to a landing page, automate a conversation that asks for the user's email directly. Marketer Gannon Meyers uses this to convert 65-70% of commenters into subscribers, a huge jump from the typical 45-50% landing page conversion rate.

The single biggest lever for cold email success isn't the copy or sending strategy—it's the offer. Truly compelling, high-value propositions, such as fundraising for a fast-growing startup or an M&A inquiry, will inherently generate high response rates.

Adding a deeply personal postscript (P.S.) to cold emails, such as referencing the recipient's favorite whiskey, demonstrates genuine research and builds rapport. This simple tactic humanizes the outreach and can dramatically increase the likelihood of getting a response from a busy executive.

Instead of trying to convince prospects of your product's value in an initial message, focus on being an interesting person they'd want to talk to. If your targeting is correct, a genuine conversation will naturally uncover their demand and lead to a sales call.

Instead of cold prospecting with a hard pitch, re-engage dormant contacts with a simple, human message: "I was thinking of you and wanted to catch up." This low-pressure approach feels authentic, yields a much higher response rate, and effectively turns cold outreach into warm conversations.

Asking for a prospect's time or interest is less effective than giving them something valuable. Emails that include a tangible offer (e.g., a benchmark, an audit, a unique insight) see a 28% higher reply rate. You get their time by not asking for it directly.

To achieve a high reply rate (10%) on massive cold email campaigns, the first email must provide upfront value without an ask. For example, find relevant Reddit threads where a prospect's product isn't mentioned, add a comment about it yourself, and then email them the links as proof of value. The pitch only comes after they respond.