Get your free personalized podcast brief

We scan new podcasts and send you the top 5 insights daily.

After Air Force leaders wrote that there was more knowledge in the audience than on the podium, Adam Grant asked the same critics for advice for next time. Their suggestions, including naming his junior appearance, were actionable; he says advice looks forward while feedback looks backward.

Related Insights

People become defensive when given unsolicited advice. To create an opening for constructive criticism, first ask the other person for feedback on your own performance. This act of vulnerability establishes trust and often triggers a natural social tendency for them to reciprocate, making them more receptive to your feedback in return.

A three-step structure for feedback: state a neutral observation ("What"), explain its impact ("So What"), and suggest a collaborative next step ("Now What"). This focuses on the work, not the person, making the feedback more likely to be received well and acted upon.

Encouragement feels good, but it doesn't foster growth. Actively seek out harsh, detailed feedback from trusted sources. Eight pages of notes on why a script "sucks" is more valuable than a hundred compliments because it provides a clear, actionable roadmap for improvement and accelerates your progress.

Asking "What did you think?" often leads to polite but unhelpful responses. By reframing the question to "What can we do better?", you explicitly invite constructive criticism, signaling an openness to improvement and making customers more comfortable sharing honest, valuable feedback.

Early leadership mistakes often stem from a perceived need to have all the answers. A more powerful approach is to express confidence in the mission while openly asking your team for feedback on how you can improve as a leader to better serve them and the company.

People often give vague praise when asked a general question like, "Any feedback?" To get useful critiques, ask for specific input on an area you're developing (e.g., "What's one thing I could do to make this meeting more effective?"). This lowers the social barrier and generates actionable advice.

When giving feedback, structure it in three parts. "What" is the specific observation. "So what" explains its impact on you or the situation. "Now what" provides a clear, forward-looking suggestion for change. This framework ensures feedback is understood and actionable.

Instead of offering unsolicited advice, first ask for permission. Frame the feedback around a shared goal (e.g., "I know you want to be the best leader possible") and then ask, "I spotted something that's getting in the way. Could I tell you about it?" This approach makes the recipient far more willing to listen and act.

When given unclear feedback like 'be more strategic,' don't ask for a definition. Instead, ask for concrete examples: 'What would it have looked like for me to be strategic?' or 'What would you have done differently?' This forces managers to provide actionable guidance instead of abstract criticism.

The framing of your request dictates the response you receive. Asking for 'feedback' puts someone in the mindset of a critic, inviting judgment. Asking for 'advice,' however, reframes them as a collaborative partner, making them an ally invested in your success.

Request next-time advice instead of retrospective feedback | RiffOn