This popular DEI phrase is a "fair-weather" inclusion policy that ignores structural inequities. It asks marginalized workers to be vulnerable in environments that are often unsafe, shifting the burden of "authenticity" onto those most at risk of being harmed by it.

Related Insights

The recent wave of mass layoffs has exposed the superficiality of corporate buzzwords like "empowerment." The concept has lost meaning because it was not backed by genuine job security or agency during difficult times. This has created a reckoning where employees see company relationships as more transactional.

Pinterest's CEO reframes the DEI debate by stating it is not in conflict with meritocracy, but a requirement for it. A system that isn't inclusive inherently limits its talent pool, making it less meritorious. By focusing on inclusion, Pinterest gained an "unfair share of great talent" and outperformed competitors.

Instead of trying to convince people of the importance of vulnerability, first have them identify their core values. They will naturally conclude that living up to those values (e.g., courage, excellence) requires them to embrace the uncertainty and risk inherent in vulnerability.

The call for radical workplace honesty ignores the psychological reality that most people view themselves through a self-serving, biased lens. Their "honesty" is often a projection of an inflated self-concept, as true self-awareness is rare and rarely aligned with how others perceive them.

The directive to 'stay in your lane' is often used to silence dissent. Counter this by expanding your definition of your lane beyond your industry expertise (e.g., marketing) to include your fundamental values (e.g., empowering women). This reframes speaking out as staying true to your authentic mission.

Innovation is stifled when team members, especially junior ones, don't feel safe to contribute. Without psychological safety, potentially industry-defining ideas are never voiced for fear of judgment. This makes it a critical business issue, not just a 'soft' HR concept.

Passion has a dark side in the workplace. Highly passionate individuals are often less likely to negotiate their salary because they worry that bringing up money will make others doubt the authenticity of their commitment. This can lead to them being underpaid and exploited.

The popular 'warts-and-all' leadership style can be perceived as weakness if the company culture values a more traditional, stoic approach. Leaders must first assess their organization's unwritten rules of leadership and then decide whether to conform, subtly push for change, or find a new environment.

Policies like Target's mandatory smiling rule create "emotional labor" that often fails as a customer service strategy. Customers can distinguish between a forced smile and genuine happiness. True customer satisfaction stems not from mandating emotions, but from creating a work environment where employees are genuinely content.

People instinctively categorize others based on identity markers, meaning leaders will always be "missorted" through flawed assumptions. Instead of fighting this, effective leaders must accept this reality and act authentically, rather than becoming paralyzed by attempts at perception management.