China’s geography creates three distinct population centers (North, Shanghai, South). These regions have separate identities and have often integrated more with global trade than with each other, making political unity a fragile, imposed state rather than an organic one.
Unlike China's vast, easily unified plains, Europe's geography of mountains and rivers created natural barriers. This prevented a single empire from dominating and instead fostered centuries of intense competition between states. This constant conflict spurred rapid technological and military innovation, ultimately leading to European dominance.
Unlike in the West, China's economic dysfunctions like industrial overcapacity paradoxically strengthen its global position. This creates massive trade surpluses and investment leverage, forcing other nations to welcome Chinese capital and increasing Beijing's geopolitical heft.
Applying James C. Scott's concept of "Zomia," Southwest China and its mountainous surroundings are best understood as a historical refuge for peoples escaping state power. This shaped their unique agricultural, social, and cultural practices designed for evasion.
China is structurally incapable of displacing the U.S. due to a trio of critical weaknesses: Xi Jinping's consolidation of power has paralyzed decision-making, geography boxes in its military, and an irreversible demographic crisis signals imminent collapse.
Deng Xiaoping’s reforms, which ignited China’s growth, were based on adopting American free-market principles like private enterprise and foreign capital. China’s success stemmed from decentralizing its economy, the very system the U.S. is now tempted to abandon for a more centralized model.
China's government sets top-down priorities like dominating EVs. This directive then cascades to provinces and prefectures, which act as hundreds of competing, state-backed venture capital funds, allocating capital and talent to achieve the national strategic goal in a decentralized but aligned way.
Contrary to the view of a monolithic state, China's economic strength comes from intense competition between its provinces. This hyper-local market forces companies to become incredibly resilient, and only the strongest, like BYD, survive to dominate globally.
While China supports institutions like the UN, its primary strategy for global influence is creating new, economically-focused organizations like the BRICS Bank and regional summits (e.g., China-Africa). This approach builds alternative power centers and economic interdependence with the Global South, supplementing rather than directly challenging the post-war Western order.
Contrary to the Western perception of a monolithic state-run system, China fosters intense competition among its provinces. Provincial leaders are incentivized to outperform each other, leading to massive, parallel innovation in industries like EVs and solar, creating a brutally efficient ecosystem.
Contrary to its national narrative, a unified China is a rare exception. Its 3,000-year history is dominated by 29 civilizational collapses where the central state fails, warlords rise, and the population plummets. Unity is not its natural state.