Facing investors who started calls by saying they rarely invest, Natalie Gordon began her pitch with a slide showing $250M in revenue. VCs would assume it was GMV, and when corrected, their skepticism vanished. The surprise forced them to take the meeting seriously.
Related Insights
A company with over $9M ARR was initially ignored by investors because it didn't fit the typical early-stage YC profile. Once its revenue was revealed at Demo Day, it became the hottest deal, showing that non-traditional, more mature companies in YC can be overlooked champions.
Top founders fundraise like a confident person on a first date. They project that their company will succeed with or without a specific investor's money. This shifts the dynamic from seeking capital to offering a strategic partnership, forcing VCs to justify why they should be on the cap table.
Instead of being discouraged by over 100 rejections, Canva's founder treated each one as a data point. She added new slides to her pitch deck to pre-emptively address every objection—such as market size or competition—making the pitch stronger and more compelling with each "no."
Applying the "weird if it didn't work" framework to fundraising means shifting the narrative. Your goal is to construct a story where the market opportunity is so massive and your team's approach is so compelling that an investor's decision *not* to participate would feel like an obvious miss.
Merge's founder views the seed round not just as a capital raise but as a test of street smarts and sales skills. How a founder manages intros, creates FOMO, and navigates the "dating game" with VCs is a direct indicator of their future success in acquiring actual customers.
Investors like Stacy Brown-Philpot and Aileen Lee now expect founders to demonstrate a clear, rapid path to massive scale early on. The old assumption that the next funding round would solve for scalability is gone; proof is required upfront.
Instead of walking into a pitch unprepared, Reid Hoffman advises founders to use large language models to pre-emptively critique their business idea. Prompting an AI to act as a skeptical VC helps founders anticipate tough questions and strengthen their narrative before meeting real investors.
While his vision for serving the SMB market via MSPs was consistently rejected, Kyle Hanslovan eventually won over investors by focusing on hard data. By proving the model with strong KPIs like top-of-funnel conversion, net dollar retention, and cash flow, he made the opportunity undeniable, even to skeptics.
Great founders turn a pitch into a collaborative discussion by asking investors to identify business weaknesses. This signals curiosity, strength, and a desire for genuine feedback over just presenting a perfect picture. It demonstrates a coachable leader who is focused on gathering data to improve.
Founders often believe fundraising failure stems from a lack of connections. However, for early-stage consumer brands with low sales figures, the real barrier is insufficient traction data. VCs need proof of scalability, like a major distribution deal, before they will invest, regardless of the introduction.