A company with over $9M ARR was initially ignored by investors because it didn't fit the typical early-stage YC profile. Once its revenue was revealed at Demo Day, it became the hottest deal, showing that non-traditional, more mature companies in YC can be overlooked champions.
Related Insights
While YC is often perceived as a B2B-centric accelerator, a significant portion of its latest batch and its most valuable alumni—like Airbnb, Reddit, and DoorDash—are consumer-facing. This suggests a persistent, successful, but often overlooked, consumer track within the accelerator.
Contrary to the 'get in early' mantra, the certainty of a 3-5x return on a category-defining company like Databricks can be a more attractive investment than a high-risk seed deal. The time and risk-adjusted returns for late-stage winners are often superior.
YC provides a built-in go-to-market engine where startups treat their 200+ well-funded batchmates as their first customers. This 'win YC, win the market' strategy de-risks early customer acquisition and provides critical initial revenue and case studies to build momentum.
The current fundraising environment is the most binary in recent memory. Startups with the "right" narrative—AI-native, elite incubator pedigree, explosive growth—get funded easily. Companies with solid but non-hype metrics, like classic SaaS growers, are finding it nearly impossible to raise capital. The middle market has vanished.
Y Combinator's model pushes companies to raise at high valuations, often bypassing traditional seed rounds. Simultaneously, mega-funds cherry-pick the most proven founders at prices seed funds cannot compete with. This leaves traditional seed funds fighting for a narrowing and less attractive middle ground.
Founders often mistake $1M ARR for product-market fit. The real milestone is proven repeatability: a predictable way to find and win a specific customer profile who reliably renews and expands. This signal of a scalable business model typically emerges closer to the $5M-$10M ARR mark.
In industries with long sales cycles like healthcare, early traction isn't about dozens of logos. For YC's Demo Day, Aegis focused on securing just one large medical billing company as a happy, paying customer. Deep engagement—evidenced by data sharing and product co-development—is a powerful early signal for investors.
Merge intentionally avoided charging its first customers. Once enough pipeline was built, they "turned on" revenue to manufacture a rapid growth story ($0 to $1M in 7 months), creating powerful momentum for fundraising, hiring, and marketing.
Elite seed funds investing in YC companies with millions in ARR are effectively pre-Series A investors. Their portfolio companies can become profitable and scale significantly on seed capital alone ("seed strapping"), making the traditional "Series A graduation rate" an outdated measure of a seed fund's success.
Y Combinator's deal flow has become so dominant that VCs who previously avoided it now attend Demo Day to stay competitive, with some even considering investing against their fund's explicit mandate to avoid missing out on top-tier companies.