We scan new podcasts and send you the top 5 insights daily.
Brent Johnson compares current American institutional strife to Rome between 120 and 60 BC. Rather than forecasting outright collapse like the Soviet Union, he argues history suggests political dysfunction and external strains typically lead to central consolidation under executive empire status.
In conceptualizing 'superpower suicide,' Snyder argues that leaders undermining American democratic institutions view the Soviet collapse as an inspirational template rather than a warning. Aspiring oligarchs who depend on state power to acquire personal wealth see the end of the Soviet Union as a moment where a few individuals broke public systems to seize resources. This mindset drives policies aimed at breaking down national institutions for personal gain.
Current American political turmoil is not about personalities but the structural breakdown of both major parties. Each has lost key voter factions, creating a chaotic period where neither can truly win. This instability will persist until a new political alignment emerges.
History shows the U.S. has a unique ability for systemic reform in response to crises, such as when the Gilded Age's excesses gave way to the deep structural changes of the Progressive Era. This suggests a capacity to overcome today's political fractures.
While past empires collapsed from debt and money printing, Arthur Laffer argues America's system is different. Its democratic processes, free markets, and checks and balances create a more flexible structure. This allows for self-correction (like Reagan following Carter), a feature that more rigid historical empires lacked.
Criticisms of a president's 'authoritarian tendencies' often miss the historical context. The concentration of power in the executive branch, or 'imperial presidency,' is a long-standing issue in U.S. politics, dating back to at least FDR and Nixon, and is often exacerbated by a weak and ineffective Congress.
Our current era of multiple, simultaneous crises is not unique but follows a historical pattern of complex systems collapse. Like the Roman and Mayan empires, civilizations become too bureaucratic, resource-intensive, and interconnected. They don't fall to invaders but rather buckle under their own complexity, leading to an inevitable, system-wide simplification.
Like the Roman Empire after defeating Carthage, the US lacks a major external enemy, risking its aggressive energy turning inward. Having no external threat to unite against, internal divisions over wealth and power can escalate into civil strife, a historical pattern for dominant powers that achieve total victory.
Acemoglu likens the decline of left liberalism to the fall of Rome, asserting its current crisis is a result of internal weaknesses and misuse of establishment power over the last 70-80 years, rather than simply the strength of external ideological challenges.
The perception of national decline in the US is not limited to one political side. Polling indicates that both left and right-leaning citizens believe the country's constitutional order and institutions are breaking down. The key difference is that each side is simply happy when their faction is temporarily "winning" the process of collapse.
Snyder argues that modern democratic backsliding stems from lingering imperial habits. Historically, European empires applied rights to an internal group while exploiting an out-group. For former expanding powers like the United States, maintaining a viable republic requires moving past the instinct to create internal tiers of citizenship, mass incarceration, or disenfranchisement, and instead embracing universal rights; otherwise, societies risk sliding back into oligarchy or imperial collapse.