We scan new podcasts and send you the top 5 insights daily.
The tech-driven 1990s Gulf War made tungsten seem obsolete. However, the prolonged, attritional nature of the war in Ukraine has forced a strategic rethink, highlighting the renewed need for basic, physically effective munitions where tungsten is a key component.
The conflict in Ukraine exposed the vulnerability of expensive, "exquisite" military platforms (like tanks) to inexpensive technologies (like drones). This has shifted defense priorities toward cheap, mass-producible, "attritable" systems. This fundamental change in product and economics creates a massive opportunity for startups to innovate outside the traditional defense prime model.
The current munitions crisis is an opportunity to shift from expensive, slow-to-produce weapons like JASM-ERs to cheaper, modular systems. This rebalancing is necessary because high-end "exquisite" technologies have long, tenuous supply chains and cannot be produced at the scale required for a major conflict.
The US Defense Industrial Base is optimized for a few high-cost, technologically advanced platforms. This model fails to meet the demands of modern conflicts, which require large volumes of affordable, attritable hardware to counter tactics used by adversaries in Ukraine and the Middle East.
While state control is a factor, China's 80% market share in tungsten is fundamentally due to possessing the world's highest-grade and most abundant geological deposits. This natural advantage makes it economically difficult for mines in other countries to compete during peacetime.
The operational status of specific tungsten mines has historically correlated with the onset of major global conflicts. Mines open just before wars (WWI, WWII, Korea) and close when peace returns, as investors place real capital bets on impending military demand.
Beyond military use, 80% of tungsten is for industrial tooling. A shortage, as seen in Nazi Germany late in WWII, directly degrades a nation's entire manufacturing base. Allied soldiers noted captured German tanks were terribly made because they lacked tungsten carbide for tooling.
The urgent need to replenish munitions for Ukraine and prepare for a Taiwan contingency is directly undermined by dependency on Chinese rare earths. Chinese export control laws can automatically deny sales to defense users, creating an acute short-term vulnerability for a Western defense industrial base holding limited stockpiles.
While media outlets create hype cycles around certain critical materials like rare earths, other equally vital commodities such as tungsten and tin face similar geopolitical supply risks but receive far less attention. These 'un-hyped' bottlenecks present significant investment opportunities for diligent researchers.
Contrary to expectations of a high-tech war, the conflict in Ukraine demonstrates enduring principles of warfare. The superiority of defense over offense, the difficulty of breakthroughs without air power, and the tendency toward attrition are all classic lessons that would be recognizable to strategists from past major conflicts.
The US military's 30-year strategy, born from the Gulf War, of relying on small numbers of technologically superior weapons is flawed. The war in Ukraine demonstrates that protracted, industrial-scale conflicts are won by mass and production volume, not just technological sophistication.