Focusing on immigration misses a deeper issue: a systemic failure to inculcate core American values in both children and newcomers. A nation with a "distressing number of people... that hate America" becomes internally weak and vulnerable to fragmentation, regardless of its border policies.

Related Insights

Reframe patriotism not as blind nationalism, but as acknowledging the immense, unearned privilege of one's birthplace and its opportunities. This creates a sense of gratitude and responsibility—a debt owed to the society, systems, and people whose sacrifices created that environment of opportunity.

The core threat to society and democracy is not political division but economic inequality. A lack of mobility creates a "crisis of hope," particularly in overlooked regions like rural America. This hopelessness leads to anger and irrational behavior that erodes democratic foundations.

The U.S. has a unique global advantage in attracting the world's most brilliant minds, akin to getting the top draft pick in sports every year. However, current restrictive policies turn this talent away, sending them to competitor nations and stunting American innovation.

Rising calls for socialist policies are not just about wealth disparity, but symptoms of three core failures: unaffordable housing, fear of healthcare-driven bankruptcy, and an education system misaligned with job outcomes. Solving these fundamental problems would alleviate the pressure for radical wealth redistribution far more effectively.

Instead of incremental shifts around a moderate center (e.g., between 4 and 6 on a dial), US policy now swings violently between ideological extremes (3 and 9). This dynamic makes stable, consensus-based governance on issues like immigration nearly impossible.

Fiscal priorities, such as cutting food benefits for children while the nation possesses immense wealth, are not just economic decisions. They are a stark revelation of a country's values, showing a shift from a society with winners and losers to one resembling "The Hunger Games."

Western education systems have spent decades teaching students that nationalism is dangerous and universal humanity is the true political community. This creates a strategic weakness, as states cannot expect these same generations to instantly adopt a strong national identity and be willing to fight for their country when a geopolitical crisis demands it.

The choice between a competitive, market-based system and a European-style welfare state is not just economic. It's a choice between America's "hardcore" identity, which values risk-taking and innovation, and Europe's model of "managed decline," which prioritizes security over global influence and dynamism.

The crisis facing young men is fundamentally economic. Their declining viability as providers prevents family formation, a cornerstone of societal stability. This economic frustration leads to anger and radicalization, making the "lonely, broke young man" a uniquely destabilizing force in society.

Society functions because humans cooperate based on shared beliefs like values or religion. These systems act as a shorthand for trust and alignment, allowing cooperation between strangers. This makes the erosion of a common value set the most significant threat to societal cohesion.

America's Core Problem Is a Failure to Instill Its Values, Not Just Immigration Policy | RiffOn