Fathom's Zoom Marketplace launch attracted 100,000 signups, but they were primarily free users with no meetings. This resulted in only 100 daily active users, highlighting the danger of vanity metrics and the importance of channel-market fit, not just massive top-of-funnel.
Related Insights
When your first users sign up but never return, it's a clear signal of a problem-solution mismatch. Before abandoning the idea, you must interview these users to understand why. Their feedback is crucial data needed to decide whether to iterate or pivot.
A more accurate measurement system can be intimidating because it reveals uncomfortable truths. It may show that seemingly successful activities, like generating high MQL volume, had a negligible impact on actual pipeline. Leaders must prepare to face this exposure to truly improve performance.
Vanity metrics like total revenue can be misleading. A startup might acquire many low-priced, low-usage customers without solving a core problem. Deep, consistent user engagement statistics are a much stronger indicator of genuine, 'found' demand than top-line numbers alone.
Many founders mistakenly define Product-Market Fit by revenue (e.g., "$1M ARR"). The correct measure is the ability to predictably create customer value. This is best quantified by a leading indicator for long-term retention, not sales figures, as revenue can be achieved without true market fit.
The true indicator of Product-Market Fit isn't how fast you can sign up new users, but how effectively you can retain them. High growth with high churn is a false signal that leads to a plateau, not compounding growth.
Platforms optimize for their own goals, not yours. Don't mistake their vanity metrics (views, likes) for key business drivers. A clip with 100 million views can have an imperceptible impact on core goals like long-form downloads or newsletter sign-ups. Constantly ask "why" a metric matters to avoid platform capture.
Despite attracting the wrong users, Fathom leveraged the high volume of signups to rapidly iterate on their onboarding process. This allowed them to achieve statistically significant results daily, ultimately improving their onboarding success rate from 30% to over 70%, turning a crisis into an asset.
Sales are a vanity metric for product-market fit. The real test is having ~25 customers who have successfully implemented your product and achieved the specific ROI promised during the sales process. If you don't have this, you have a product problem, not a go-to-market problem.
Winning accolades like Product of the Day/Week/Month provides an initial user spike but doesn't guarantee product-market fit. True PMF is indicated by sustained, accelerating organic word-of-mouth growth, not a launch-driven bump that later flattens out.
Counterintuitively, a high freemium conversion rate (e.g., 7%) isn't always positive. It may indicate the free plan is too restrictive, failing to build a wide user base that provides network effects, referrals, or a long-term upgrade pipeline. The goal is a broad top-of-funnel, not just quick conversions.
