We scan new podcasts and send you the top 5 insights daily.
Unsolicited cold calls for off-list reference checks rarely yield actionable or candid assessments from peers. Effective reference calls rely on concentric circles of trust and warm introductions, where shared relationships encourage sources to corroborate potential red flags honestly.
Standard reference checks yield generic praise. To identify true A-players, ask their former colleagues a high-stakes question: “Would you quit your current job to work for this person again?” An enthusiastic “yes” is the strongest hiring signal you can get.
For hiring, Scott Galloway advocates for prioritizing "reference hiring" above all else. He trusts a strong recommendation from a credible source so much that he considers the candidate an "80, 90% lock on the job" before they even interview. This suggests vetted referrals are a far more reliable signal of quality than traditional interview performance.
Artemis moves reference checks to the beginning of their hiring process, not the end. They've found an almost perfect correlation between the strength of references and on-the-job performance. This allows them to de-risk candidates and make high-conviction offers within just one or two days.
Standard reference calls are predictably positive. To get the truth, ask the reference, "What job do we need to hire next to help this person be successful?" The description of the required role will almost always be a perfect antonym of the candidate's skills, revealing their weaknesses.
When hiring for corp dev roles, assess abstract qualities like work ethic and resilience by asking candidates specific probing questions. Then, ask their provided references the exact same questions to see if the stories corroborate and gain a true sense of character.
Interviews are often misleading. A trusted recommendation from a high-performing employee or contact is a more reliable signal of a candidate's quality than your own interview assessment. This "reference hiring" is a secret weapon for building a strong team.
Candidate-provided reference calls almost always produce inflated praise because candidates curate positive referrers. To derive actionable predictive signal, Bending Spoons structures reference interviews by demanding forced comparative ratings. Asking a referrer whether the candidate ranks in the absolute top tier out of the last 20 colleagues often reveals that a supposedly exceptional individual is merely considered above average.
Zipline considers candidate-provided references to be useless ("paid references"). Instead, they invest significant time to network their way to former colleagues not on the official list. These blind references provide brutally honest feedback, revealing both A+ players and those who "leave a trail of destruction."
For the first 40 hires, the founder relied exclusively on people he had worked with directly or people recommended by trusted professional colleagues. He emphasizes qualifying the recommender, distinguishing between a friend who is fun and a colleague who is excellent at their job, ensuring a high-quality initial team.
Standard reference checks yield polite platitudes. To elicit honesty, frame the call around the high stakes for both your company and the candidate. Emphasize that a bad fit hurts the candidate's career and wastes everyone's time. This forces the reference to provide a more candid, risk-assessed answer.