Established companies like Pepsi only embraced social-first marketing after agile competitors like Liquid Death and Prime used it to attack their market share. The tangible pain of losing business, not the promise of innovation, was the ultimate catalyst for legacy brands to finally change their strategies.

Related Insights

When leadership resists a modern, low-budget content approach, use social proof as leverage. Find examples of competitors succeeding with this exact strategy (e.g., TikToks, lo-fi videos). Presenting this evidence creates social pressure and a sense of urgency that is often more persuasive than a theoretical pitch.

Established industries often operate like cartels with unwritten rules, such as avoiding aggressive marketing. New entrants gain a significant edge by deliberately violating these norms, forcing incumbents to react to a game they don't want to play. This creates differentiation beyond the core product or service.

Instead of a single national campaign, Pepsi armed its local bottlers with camcorders to run the "Pepsi Challenge" in their own communities. Using local TV spots with real people, they created an authentic, grassroots movement that a centralized giant like Coca-Cola was ill-equipped to counter.

Coca-Cola thumbnail

Coca-Cola

Acquired3 months ago

Most product categories are commodities with minimal functional differences. Success, as shown by Liquid Death in the water category, hinges on building an emotional connection through branding and packaging, which are the primary drivers of consumer choice over minor product benefits.

Key Opinion Leaders (KOLs) and creators are shifting from being brand partners to direct competitors. They leverage their audiences to launch their own products (e.g., Prime vs. Gatorade), posing a significant strategic threat to established CPG brands by bypassing traditional retail and marketing.

Large CPG players have slow, agency-driven feedback loops. Nimble DTC brands can win by rapidly testing creative, messaging, and offers online, gaining an insurmountable learning advantage. Speed itself becomes the strategic edge, not just a byproduct of being small.

When competing against a resourceful incumbent, a startup's key advantage is speed. Bizzabo outmaneuvered its rival during the pandemic by launching a virtual solution in weeks, not months. This agility allows challenger brands to seize market shifts that larger players are too slow to address.

Blippar found that large, established companies wanted to fit new tech into old media silos (e.g., play a TV ad on a print ad). In contrast, challenger brands like Juice Burst were dream clients. Their risk appetite and hunger for an edge made them willing to experiment and create truly innovative use cases.

Large brands are falling into the trap of "small brand envy," trying to replicate the playbooks of agile D2C startups. This is a flawed strategy, as the tactics required to maintain market leadership are fundamentally different from those used for initial growth.

Vanguard's marketing became crucial when the company transitioned from a market disruptor to an incumbent being copied. The initial disruption created its own buzz, but as a market leader, Vanguard had to actively invest in marketing to differentiate its message.