Vanguard's marketing became crucial when the company transitioned from a market disruptor to an incumbent being copied. The initial disruption created its own buzz, but as a market leader, Vanguard had to actively invest in marketing to differentiate its message.
Established industries often operate like cartels with unwritten rules, such as avoiding aggressive marketing. New entrants gain a significant edge by deliberately violating these norms, forcing incumbents to react to a game they don't want to play. This creates differentiation beyond the core product or service.
While product differentiation is beneficial, it's not always possible. A brand's most critical job is to be distinctive and instantly recognizable. This mental availability, achieved through consistent creative, logo, and tone, is more crucial for cutting through market noise than having a marginally different feature set.
Colin Kelton, Vanguard's CMO, had no formal marketing background. He succeeded by acknowledging his gaps and hiring deeply knowledgeable experts, proving that business acumen paired with a strong team can be more valuable than a traditional marketing pedigree.
High-growth companies must transition from performance to brand marketing. The best marketers make this shift proactively, using experience to anticipate the inflection point. Waiting for data to confirm the need leads to inefficiency and a potential "death spiral."
Startups often fail by making a slightly better version of an incumbent's product. This is a losing strategy because the incumbent can easily adapt. The key is to build something so fundamentally different in structure that competitors have a very hard time copying it, ensuring a durable advantage.
When facing massive incumbents, avoid the trap of creating a slightly better version of their product. Instead, focus on being fundamentally different. Gamma chose to break the 16x9 slide paradigm that PowerPoint established, creating new primitives for visual communication.
Vanguard's ability to adopt AI was a direct result of a prior project to consolidate its fragmented "marketing tech pile" into a unified platform. This foundational investment was the critical enabler, proving that future innovation depends on present-day infrastructure cleanup.
Founder Jack Bogle noted Vanguard's investor-owned structure was never copied because "there's no money in it" for external shareholders. The model's core competitive advantage is its inherent unprofitability for anyone but the end customer, making it unattractive for competitors.
David Aaker posits that true market growth comes only from disruptive innovation, not from "my brand is better than yours" incrementalism. He criticizes seminal works on innovation for ignoring that branding is essential to position the new category, build barriers to entry, and make the innovation successful.
Founder Jack Bogle questioned marketing spend, not realizing his constant public criticism of the industry and passionate advocacy was a powerful, free form of content marketing. Modern marketing's job became scaling and replacing that initial founder-led energy.