The founder of restaurant 11 Madison Park used "reverse benchmarking" by analyzing competitors not for their strengths, but for their weaknesses. Identifying and perfecting an overlooked detail, like their rival's merely average coffee service, created their competitive edge.
Instead of copying what top competitors do well, analyze what they do poorly or neglect. Excelling in those specific areas creates a powerful differentiator. This is how Eleven Madison Park focused on rivals' bad coffee service to become the world's #1 restaurant.
In crowded markets, founders mistakenly focus on other startups as primary competition. In reality, most customers are unaware of these players. The real battle is against the customer's status quo: their current tools like spreadsheets, hiring a person, or using an old system. Your job is to beat those options.
After realizing their food alone couldn't beat the competition, restaurant 11 Madison Park pivoted to obsessing over service. They differentiated by making the entire customer experience—not just the product—their unique selling proposition.
Instead of fixating on competitors, Red Ventures built its success by focusing on compounding its own performance month-over-month. This internal benchmark created a virtuous cycle addicted to incremental improvement, which became a more powerful and sustainable growth engine than reactive, market-focused competition.
Startups often fail by making a slightly better version of an incumbent's product. This is a losing strategy because the incumbent can easily adapt. The key is to build something so fundamentally different in structure that competitors have a very hard time copying it, ensuring a durable advantage.
The fundamental goal is to become a "better competitive alternative" for a specific customer—being so superior that they bypass competitors to choose you. Achieving this state is the business equivalent of the house advantage in a casino (“the house vig”) and the only reliable way to build a lasting enterprise.
Industries widely considered "terrible businesses," like restaurants, often signal opportunity. The high failure rate is usually due to a low barrier to entry and a lack of business acumen among participants. A disciplined, business-first approach in such an environment can create a massive and durable competitive advantage.
When competing against a large incumbent, reframe the comparison away from company vs. company. Instead, frame it as you—the dedicated founder—versus their salaried, indifferent employee. This shifts the focus from resources to personal commitment, turning your small size into an advantage.
Instead of matching rivals' strengths, identify their weaknesses or overlooked details, like a poor coffee program. Focusing on these neglected areas allows you to create a unique, best-in-class experience and gain a competitive foothold. Guidara's team calls this 'reverse benchmarking.'
A competitor may have a "better" product on paper, but buyers' demand is nuanced. A founder can win a deal against a well-funded rival by discovering the buyer's primary need is industry expertise, not more features. By aligning with this deeper "pull," the competitor's strengths become irrelevant.