Contrary to the classic marketing "rule of seven," recent research shows that focusing on two to three high-impact, emotionally resonant messages is more effective than mass repetition. In a noisy environment, concentrated, potent creative breaks through where sheer volume fails.

Many product launches fail because marketers change core messaging too frequently, confusing both customers and their own sales teams. The key is consistency. Instead of constant overhauls, put creative "wrinkles" on the same core message to maintain brand clarity and impact, just as top consumer brands do.

Tushy's growth and brand teams collaborate to ensure ads drive performance without damaging long-term brand equity. They moved away from certain high-performing creative after asking if it created the right 'memory structure' for an increasingly premium product, prioritizing long-term perception over short-term wins.

The most effective long-term campaigns use "disguised repetition"—keeping core brand assets consistent while introducing fresh creative elements, like Aldi's Kevin the Carrot—to build memory structures without causing audience fatigue.

Contrary to the belief that ads quickly wear out, strong creative often performs better with repeated exposure. This concept of "wear in" justifies patience, allowing a new campaign to build familiarity and emotional connection with the audience, as stories grow resonance over time.

Data shows that brand-building ads rarely suffer from "wear out." Amazon successfully reran their "Sledging Grannies" ad two years later, and it tested with the exact same effectiveness, proving that great creative has a long shelf life.

Once ad copy proves to resonate with a target market, it may not need to be changed. A multi-million dollar ad campaign ran for a full year with the same copy, focusing solely on testing and rotating new creative visuals to maintain effectiveness and reach new audiences.

The common marketing belief in ad "wear out" is wrong, as familiarity breeds contentment, not contempt. Consequently, marketers often pull their advertising campaigns right at the point where repetition is making them most effective.

Familiarity breeds contentment, not contempt. The 'Mere Exposure Effect' shows that repeated exposure to a stimulus makes us feel more positive towards it. This explains why consistent campaigns outperform those that frequently change creative. The performance gap between effective, consistent campaigns and inconsistent ones widens dramatically over time, creating a compounding advantage.