Substack's founder predicts AI will eliminate mediocre content. The winners will be at the extremes: either maximally authentic and human (like live streams) or perfectly polished and AI-generated. Everything in the messy, semi-polished middle will struggle to compete.

Related Insights

Sam Altman argues the AI vs. human content debate is a false dichotomy. The dominant creative form will be a hybrid where humans use AI as a tool. Consumers will ultimately judge content on its quality and originality ('is it slop?'), not on its method of creation.

The future of media is not just recommended content, but content rendered on-the-fly for each user. AI will analyze micro-behaviors like eye movement and swipe speed to generate the most engaging possible video in that exact moment. The algorithm will become the content itself.

As AI-generated 'slop' floods platforms and reduces their utility, a counter-movement is brewing. This creates a market opportunity for new social apps that can guarantee human-created and verified content, appealing to users fatigued by endless AI.

The definition of "AI slop" is evolving from obviously fake images to a flood of perfectly polished, generic, and boring content. As AI makes flattering imagery cheap to produce, authentic, unpolished, and even unflattering content becomes more valuable for creators trying to stand out on platforms like Instagram.

As AI-generated content creates a sea of sameness, audiences will seek what machines cannot replicate: genuine emotion and deep, personal narrative. This will drive a creator-led shift toward more meaningful, long-form content that offers a real human connection.

The flood of AI-generated assets isn't a new problem but an amplification of an old one. It simply highlights that much of human-created content was already mediocre. AI removes resource barriers to production, making "taste" and "quality judgment" the true differentiators—skills that are now more valuable than ever.

Generative AI allows any marketer to quickly produce mediocre content. This saturation makes buyers more discerning and creates a significant opportunity for brands that invest in genuinely excellent, insightful content to stand out and build trust. Quality, not quantity, becomes the key differentiator.

In a world saturated with AI-generated content, work that is verifiably human-made will command a premium. Similar to how consumers seek out organic food, audiences will actively seek and value the authenticity, personality, and craftsmanship of human-driven content.

An AI CEO predicts that within two years, AI tools will make content creation instantaneous and nearly free. This will destroy traditional moats like audience loyalty and production quality, as anyone can generate photorealistic content. The market will shift focus from the creator to the individual content piece.

The current debate focuses on labeling AI-generated content. However, as AI content floods the internet and becomes the default, the more efficient system will be to label the smaller, scarcer category: authentic, human-created content.