Children vary in their developmental plasticity. Those most vulnerable to the negative effects of adversity are also the most likely to benefit from supportive environments. Conversely, children who are resilient in the face of hardship are often less susceptible to the positive effects of enrichment and nurturance.
Related Insights
There isn't a direct gene for ADHD or depression, but there is a 'sensitivity gene' that makes individuals more susceptible to stress. According to epigenetics, present and nurturing parenting in the first year of life can effectively neutralize the expression of this gene, preventing future mental illness.
Contrary to viewing adversity's effects as mere dysfunction, an evolutionary lens suggests they are adaptations. For example, accelerated puberty in response to a threatening environment increases the chances of passing on genes, prioritizing reproduction over long-term health, neatly summarized as 'live fast and die young.'
A powerful framework for raising resilient individuals is to separate self-worth from performance. Build immense self-esteem by praising character traits (e.g., kindness), while simultaneously enforcing radical accountability for failures (e.g., "the pitcher was better than you"). This creates confidence that isn't shattered by losing.
To raise children who thrive outside "the system," parents must shift from preventing failure to encouraging resilience. This means getting kids comfortable with losing through competition, de-emphasizing grades, and prioritizing work ethic and real-world experience over trophies.
Beyond simple resilience, "post-traumatic growth" is the scientifically-backed idea that all humans can use adversity to build a psychological immune system. Overcoming challenges creates a memory of capability, making you better equipped to handle future adversity, from losing a deal to losing a job.
The rise of 'helicopter parenting'—driven by high-profile but statistically rare media stories—has stripped childhood of unstructured, challenging experiences. Without facing minor physical and social risks (like playground fights), younger generations perceive intellectual disagreements as severe threats, leading to higher anxiety and depression.
Countering the idea that parenting has little effect on outcomes, a twin study found that the twin receiving slightly more maternal affection between ages 5-10 grew up to be more open, conscientious, and agreeable. This suggests that small, differential parenting choices have measurable long-term consequences for personality.
Trauma's definition should be tied to its outcome: any permanent change in behavior from an adverse event. This reframing allows for "positive trauma," where a difficult experience forces you to adapt and establish a new, higher-performing baseline, ultimately making you better off.
Resilience isn't a switch to be flipped during a crisis. It is the accumulated result of consistent habits, a supportive culture, and a psychological "margin" built over time. It is an outcome of intentional preparation, not an inherent trait you simply possess.
Pediatrician Donald Winnicott argued that children must learn to handle frustration and disappointment. A "perfect" parent who shields a child from all difficulty inadvertently robs them of the chance to develop coping mechanisms for the real world.
