A common agency failure is leading with their specialty (e.g., "we run Meta campaigns") rather than diagnosing the business's core needs. A strategy-first approach ties marketing directly to business objectives, ensuring the chosen tactics are appropriate and measurable, preventing wasted effort on channels that don't fit the goal.
Digital and AI are tools, not the strategy itself. Before discussing channels or technology, marketing teams must complete the foundational work: defining business objectives, growth opportunities, customer segments, and journey pain points. Digital execution flows from these strategic choices.
A client wasted $100,000 because marketers executed isolated tactics like SEO without a cohesive plan. An effective agency must first deeply understand the core business strategy—mission, growth goals, ideal clients—before implementing any marketing activities to ensure alignment and ROI.
The number one mistake in annual planning is creating a marketing strategy in a vacuum. A plan disconnected from company-wide goals, such as a major product launch, results in resource misalignment, budget shortfalls, and missed growth opportunities.
Marketing plans often fail because they are created in a vacuum. A robust marketing strategy must be built upon the company's core business strategy, including its vision, values, and business model, to ensure it supports overall objectives like growth targets.
Many large agencies are not truly consumer-centric. Their business model incentivizes focusing on winning industry awards (like Cannes Lions), pleasing internal stakeholders, and navigating corporate politics. This creates a fundamental disconnect from where consumer attention actually is, leading to ineffective marketing spend.
Marketing teams often mistake demand programs for campaign strategy. A true campaign strategy is a higher-level "canvas" that orchestrates all efforts—reputation, demand creation, and enablement—against a specific audience, ensuring a consistent customer experience rather than disjointed tactical execution.
Look for a marketing partner who will educate you and your team, not just execute tasks in a black box. The most valuable agencies explain the 'why' behind their strategies, leveling up your entire organization's marketing knowledge and fostering a more collaborative, effective relationship.
The discussion over in-house versus agency marketing is a distraction from the fundamental problem. The core failure in most marketing today—from billboards to social posts—is a lack of strategic intent. Brands are simply 'posting shit' without a clear purpose, a flaw that exists regardless of who executes the work.
Marketers are repeating a classic mistake by adopting powerful AI tools as shiny new tactics without a solid strategic foundation. This leads to ineffective, generic outputs. The core principle of "strategy first" is now more critical than ever, applying directly to technology adoption.
Forward-thinking agencies can lose business by pitching complex, integrated solutions when a client has a specific, immediate need and budget (e.g., traditional SEO). It's crucial to meet the client where they are and deliver value on their stated problem, rather than being "too proud or innovative" to do fundamental work.