Beehiiv's founder contrasted a failed crypto venture (no expertise) with his successful startup built on his Morning Brew experience. This credibility story was his primary asset for attracting early users and investors before he had revenue or traction.
Initially, the founders' pitch to 'build anything' fell flat. They found success by shifting to an honest story: 'We built amazing tech at Uber and want to bring it to your industry.' This attracted visionary customers who bought into the ambition and team credibility, not just current features.
An idea is only "good" for a specific founder if it aligns with their unique background, skills, and passions. What seems like a terrible idea to one person can be a perfect fit for another, because their life experiences give them a unique insight and unfair advantage in executing it.
Investors probe the origin of the first few customers. Hearing about crashing trade shows or intercepting people at coffee demonstrates a founder's determination and ability to get things done without a large budget or existing brand.
Don't wait for a prototype to get traction. Hardware founders should first engage potential customers and demonstrate a profound understanding of their specific problems. This expertise builds the necessary trust for customers to commit, even before a physical product is ready.
Investors are often more compelled by a founder's palpable confidence and unique understanding of a market than by the product itself. During a pitch, radiating a deep belief in a "secret" insight about your users demonstrates a level of conviction that can be more persuasive than any metric.
Instead of searching for a market to serve, founders should solve a problem they personally experience. This "bottom-up" approach guarantees product-market fit for at least one person—the founder—providing a solid foundation to build upon and avoiding the common failure of abstract, top-down market analysis.
A founder's outreach message must mature over time. Initially, it relies on personal credibility ("I'm an HBS grad"). As the company gets wins, it shifts to social proof ("we work with NASA"). Only after many conversations can it be refined into a concise, demand-driven value proposition that resonates with the target market.
Early outreach often fails by pitching an unproven value proposition. Instead, founders should use "Founder Magic"—leveraging their unique background, story, or mission to make themselves so interesting that prospects agree to a meeting out of sheer curiosity. The outreach should be product-agnostic and focus on being compelling as a person.
To make a business narrative compelling, founders should lead with a surprising, personal detail. Jeffrey Katzenberg uses his unexpected presence at Burning Man as a hook to tell an investment story, proving that a personal connection captures an audience before the business case does.
Investors see it as a significant positive signal when a founder can demonstrate a comprehensive understanding of their industry's history, including past failures and adjacent companies. This historical context indicates they have a unique angle of attack and are not simply repeating old mistakes, differentiating them from less-prepared entrepreneurs.