Philosopher Rebecca Goldstein distinguishes our need for connectedness (external validation) from our "mattering instinct," an internal drive to prove our lives have value to ourselves. Confusing these two distinct needs leads to misunderstanding human behavior.
Internal and external motivations are controlled by the same brain circuitry, operating like a binary switch. If your work environment flips you into "external motivation" mode (seeking approval, status), that switch stays flipped at home, making it impossible to access internal motivation without creating distance.
Happiness studies reveal that fulfillment comes from the active process of caring for others. The happiest individuals are not those who are the passive recipients of the most affection, but rather those who actively cultivate deep, meaningful relationships where they can give love.
A stable sense of significance comes from micro-level commitments like family and close relationships, not from trying to solve macro-level problems. Focusing on your immediate circle provides a tangible, real sense of mattering that is often elusive in broader, more abstract causes.
Therapist Terry Real distinguishes between gratification (a short-term pleasure hit) and relational joy (the profound satisfaction from being connected). Our culture champions the former, leaving even successful people feeling empty because they miss the latter.
People's diverse values and life choices can be understood through four primary "mattering strategies": transcendent (spiritual), social (communal), heroic (self-driven excellence), and competitive (zero-sum). Understanding which strategy a person uses can decode their motivations.
The desire for social validation is innate and impossible to eliminate. Instead of fighting it, harness it. Deliberately change your environment to surround yourself with people who validate the positive behaviors you want to adopt, making sustainable change easier.
The root cause of people-pleasing is often a “self-abandonment wound.” We seek validation or acceptance from others because we are trying to get something from them that we are not giving ourselves. The solution is to develop internal self-acceptance and set boundaries.
Many entrepreneurial decisions are subconsciously driven by a desire to impress a specific person—a parent, a rival, an old flame. This external validation seeking leads to poor choices and inaction. Decoding this motivation is more critical than any business tactic.
It's a profound mystery how evolution encoded high-level desires like seeking social approval. Unlike simple instincts linked to sensory input (e.g., smell), these social goals require complex brain processing to even define. The mechanism by which our genome instills a preference for such abstract concepts is unknown and represents a major gap in our understanding.
Early life experiences of inadequacy or invalidation often create deep-seated insecurities. As adults, we are subconsciously driven to pursue success in those specific areas—be it money, power, or recognition—to fill that void and gain the validation we lacked.