Go beyond standard performance-based earn-outs by structuring payments with 'kickers' that reward sellers for specific de-risking actions. For example, if there's high customer concentration, offer an additional payment for diversifying revenue away from the main client, aligning them with the buyer's risk mitigation goals.
To de-risk carve-out acquisitions, sophisticated buyers should recommend the seller commission a sell-side Quality of Earnings (QofE) report before a preliminary bid is made. A seller's willingness to invest in a QofE signals their motivation, and the report provides a more reliable financial perimeter, reducing the risk of later surprises and renegotiations.
Serial acquirer Lifco improves post-acquisition performance by having sellers retain an ownership stake in their business. This goes beyond typical earn-outs, keeping the founder's expertise and incentives aligned with the parent company for long-term growth, rather than just hitting short-term targets.
An earn-out is a tool for alignment, not just a financial hedge. If a target company is on track to miss its earn-out targets, a savvy acquirer will proactively renegotiate the terms. The long-term value of retaining and motivating the key team members outweighs the short-term financial gain of a missed payment.
Founders should be wary of earn-out clauses. Acquirers can impose layers of pointless processes and overhead costs, tanking the profitability of a successful business and making it impossible for the founder to ever receive their earn-out payment.
Earnouts rewarding only the acquired team's siloed performance create a major integration roadblock. This structure incentivizes them to hoard resources and avoid collaboration, directly undermining the goal of creating a unified culture and destroying potential cross-functional value.
To ensure sales reps focus on long-term value (LTV), structure compensation to reward customer success. Pay half the commission on contract signing and the other half only when the customer hits a predefined activation metric, known as the Leading Indicator of Retention (LIR). This forces reps to sell to right-fit customers.
Instead of offering generic bonuses, design them specifically to address the primary reason a customer might hesitate. For instance, if they're worried about implementation time, offer a bonus of free, hands-on team training to eliminate that specific objection and close the deal.
When evaluating a deal, sophisticated LPs look beyond diversifying customers and suppliers. They analyze the number of viable exit channels. A company whose only realistic exit path is an IPO faces significant hold period risk if public markets turn, making exit diversification a key resiliency metric.
Instead of jumping directly to an acquisition, de-risk the process by first establishing a partnership or licensing agreement. This allows you to test the technology, cultural fit, and market reception with a lower commitment, building a stronger foundation for a potential future deal.
To retain founders who've already cashed out, use a dual incentive. Offer rollover equity in the new parent company for long-term alignment ('a second bite at the apple'), and a cash earn-out tied to short-term growth targets. This financial structure is crucial when managing wealthy, independent operators who don't need the job.