When building an elite team, choreographer Twyla Tharp looks beyond skill. The crucial factor is the collaborator's own intense desire to work with her and tackle immense challenges. The best team members effectively select themselves by demonstrating a commitment so strong they're willing to "go through the wall."
Elite talent manifests in two primary ways. An individual is either in the top 0.01% on a single dimension (e.g., tenacity, sales), or they possess a rare Venn diagram of skills that don't typically coexist (e.g., a first-rate technologist who is also a first-rate business strategist).
To test the commitment of aspiring dancers, Twyla Tharp’s default advice is "don't do it." This seemingly discouraging response serves as a powerful filter. It weeds out those with fleeting interest, ensuring that only individuals with an absolute, undeniable internal drive will persist.
High-achievers who pursue grueling endurance challenges are often driven less by a love for the 'grind' and more by a profound curiosity. The core motivation is an intrinsic desire to understand the experience and discover their own limits, without fear of the difficulty itself.
Prioritize hiring generalist "athletes"—people who are intelligent, driven, and coachable—over candidates with deep domain expertise. Core traits like Persistence, Heart, and Desire (a "PhD") cannot be taught, but a smart athlete can always learn the product.
While knowledge is valuable, choreographer Twyla Tharp argues that a creator's most difficult and essential work is "protecting but refining instinct." The challenge is to prevent intellectual understanding and external feedback from diluting the pure, immediate, and often correct, gut reactions that drive original work.
Organizational success depends less on high-profile 'superstars' and more on 'Sherpas'—generous, energetic team players who handle the essential, often invisible, support work. When hiring, actively screen for generosity and positive energy, as these are the people who enable collective achievement.
Instead of creating a broadly appealing culture, build one that is intensely attractive to a tiny, specific niche (e.g., "we wear suits and use Windows"). This polarization repels most people but creates an incredibly strong, cohesive team from the few who are deeply drawn to it.
While psychology warns against tying your identity to your work to avoid pain from failure, high performers do exactly that. They embrace identities like "I am a writer" because this personal attachment makes excellence non-negotiable and prevents them from simply "going through the motions."
Gaining more knowledge as a creator doesn't make the process easier; it expands the field of options and raises the stakes, creating bigger challenges. Choreographer Twyla Tharp cites late-career Beethoven, whose deafness forced him into a unique, mature creative space.
Twyla Tharp reframes her famous 5 a.m. gym routine not as a cherished ritual but as a "loathsome" reality. The purpose isn't enjoyment; it's the non-negotiable work required to prepare her "instrument" for the challenges ahead. Discipline is about necessity, not passion for the routine itself.