A peaceful resolution in Ukraine would likely be bullish for oil. Russia would need to repair its refineries, increasing its domestic demand for crude oil. This internal consumption would reduce the amount of crude available for export, tightening the global market and pushing prices up.
The prospect of reviving Venezuela's vast but dormant oil industry introduces significant potential for increased global supply. Morgan Stanley suggests this could suppress prices in the medium-term, a counter-intuitive outcome where resolving geopolitical tension leads to lower commodity prices rather than higher ones.
Despite new US sanctions on Russian oil producers, Goldman Sachs remains bearish, forecasting a decline. They argue that spare capacity from OPEC, exemptions for buyers, and the reorganization of trade networks will mitigate any supply disruption, preventing a sustained price spike and leading to lower prices by 2026.
Despite the absence of a real surplus, oil prices are unlikely to surge. China has built massive strategic reserves and consistently sells from them when Brent crude moves above $70 per barrel. This acts as a ceiling on the market, creating a range-bound environment for prices in the $60s.
The primary impact of U.S. sanctions on Russian oil is not a reduction in supply but a compression of profit margins. Russia is forced to offer deeper discounts, estimated at $3-$5 per barrel below pre-sanction levels, to compensate buyers for increased logistical and financial risks, ensuring export flows remain stable.
The market has a natural floor. For U.S. shale, a WTI price of $47 represents a zero-return level where drilling and completions halt. For Russia, a Brent price below $42 means operators face negative margins, forcing well shut-ins and providing a backstop against a complete price collapse.
Despite his stated goal of lowering oil prices, President Trump's aggressive sanctions on Venezuela, Iran, and Russia have removed significant supply from the market. This creates logistical bottlenecks and "oil on water" buildups, effectively tightening the market and keeping prices higher than they would be otherwise.
US sanctions on Russian LNG facilities are not primarily about punishing Russia for Ukraine, but are a strategic move in a global "LNG war." The US is using LNG as a tool of foreign policy and national security, meaning these sanctions are unlikely to be lifted even with a peace deal.
Forecasters often miss that OPEC+ increases production based on demand for its own oil, not just overall global demand. Sanctions on rivals like Russia and Iran can boost demand for OPEC+ crude, prompting them to unwind cuts even when global demand growth seems weak.
Regional stability is an economic necessity for oil-rich nations. Peace allows them to accelerate monetization of their finite oil reserves and reinvest the capital into diversified, future-proof economies like AI and tourism before alternative energy devalues their primary asset.
Current oil prices are trading significantly above their fundamental fair value of $61/barrel. The analyst estimates that $8 of the price strength is a temporary premium due to geopolitical tensions with Iran, while only $2 is attributable to actual supply disruptions and cold weather.