While the Trump administration promotes investment in a post-Maduro Venezuela, major oil companies like ExxonMobil are publicly skeptical. Their stance that the country is "uninvestable" due to the absence of rule of law shows that political guarantees are insufficient without fundamental institutional reforms.
A rapid rebound in Venezuelan oil production is improbable, even with massive investment. The effort is constrained by fundamental infrastructure failures, like a deeply unreliable national power grid, which is essential for running upgraders and refineries. This makes a quick recovery lasting years, not months.
The crude oil market is trapped in a recurring monthly pattern. For the first half of each month, the forward curve weakens on fears of a supply glut, nearly flipping into contango. Then, a sudden geopolitical shock mid-month causes the curve to snap back into pronounced backwardation, delaying the surplus.
Despite his stated goal of lowering oil prices, President Trump's aggressive sanctions on Venezuela, Iran, and Russia have removed significant supply from the market. This creates logistical bottlenecks and "oil on water" buildups, effectively tightening the market and keeping prices higher than they would be otherwise.
The Trump administration perceives its new influence over Venezuela's vast heavy oil resources as a strategic advantage in upcoming USMCA trade negotiations. While not a direct substitute for Canadian crude, the perception of reduced dependence is being wielded as political leverage against a key trading partner.
Despite rhetoric supporting protesters in Iran and Venezuela, the Trump administration's actions suggest a preference for replacing existing leaders with more compliant strongmen. In Venezuela, this meant dealing with Maduro's VP, indicating a pragmatic focus on control and stability over messy, long-term nation-building.
The 30-50 million barrels of Venezuelan oil the White House claims to be releasing is not new supply. It's largely oil that was already produced but couldn't be exported due to the U.S. blockade. Releasing it is more of a reversal of a self-inflicted disruption than an injection of fresh barrels into the market.
The idea of using seized Venezuelan oil to refill the U.S. Strategic Petroleum Reserve (SPR) faces a major technical hurdle. The heavy, sour Venezuelan crude doesn't match the specific medium-sour grade the SPR is designed to hold. Any such plan would require complex and potentially costly barrel-for-barrel swaps.
Trump's actions are guided by a political balancing act. Research shows negative media mentions spike when gasoline exceeds $3.50/gallon. Conversely, crude below $50-$60/barrel hurts his producer base. This creates a "parabola of political price pressure," incentivizing him to keep prices within a politically safe band.