When a non-designer provides a polished mockup, designers often feel constrained to only refine it. Presenting intentionally rough sketches signals you're communicating an idea's intent, not a proposed execution, freeing designers to reimagine the solution and collaborate more creatively.
Related Insights
Inspired by Apple Stores placing iPads crooked to encourage touch, consultants should present strategies with minor flaws. This invites senior teams to "straighten" the plan, creating a feeling of ownership that makes them five times more likely to embrace and execute it.
Many founders hire UX help expecting a final "graphic design polish" on an already-defined product. The real value comes from a design partner who ideates alongside the core team from the beginning, ensuring the product's structure is coherent before it's built.
Product teams often use placeholder text and duplicate UI components, but users don't provide good feedback on unrealistic designs. A prototype with authentic, varied content—even if the UI is simpler—will elicit far more valuable user feedback because it feels real.
To accelerate design skill, seek out blunt feedback from practitioners you respect. Go beyond high-level user feedback and ask for a "roast" on the visual details. The goal is to get concrete, actionable advice—even down to specific CSS classes—to refine your taste and execution.
An interaction can look perfect in a static tool like Figma but feel terrible when built. Prototyping allows designers to experience the 'feel' of their work—a crucial step for validating ideas, developing intuition, and creating higher-quality products that you can't get from static mockups alone.
Instead of asking designers to create mockups from a verbal brief, PMs can use AI tools to generate multiple visual explorations themselves. This allows them to bring more concrete, refined ideas to the table, leading to a richer and more effective collaboration with the design team.
In design thinking, early prototypes aren't for validating a near-finished product. They are rough, low-cost "artifacts" (like bedsheets for walls) designed to help stakeholders vividly pre-experience a new reality. This generates more accurate feedback and invites interaction before significant investment.
AI prototyping tools have broken the traditional link between visual fidelity and process maturity. Designers can now create highly realistic, functional prototypes on day one. This makes it challenging to signal to stakeholders that a concept is still early and exploratory, leading to feedback on pixels instead of strategy.
With modern tools, the link between visual polish and time investment is broken. Instead of worrying about "visual fidelity," judge explorations by "effort fidelity." A high-fidelity prototype created in a day is a low-effort artifact, allowing for quick, rich feedback without over-investment.
In an AI-driven workflow, the primary value of a rapid prototype is not for design exploration but as a communication tool. It makes the product vision tangible for stakeholders in reviews, increasing credibility and buy-in far more effectively than a slide deck.
