Instead of trying to convince skeptical leadership with a presentation, carve out a small part of your budget to run a real-world test of your creative idea. Present the superior results from your experiment. Data from a live campaign is far more persuasive than a theoretical argument.
Related Insights
When pitching new marketing initiatives, supplement ROI projections with research demonstrating a clear audience need for the content. Framing the project as a valuable service to the customer, rather than just another marketing tactic, is a more powerful way to gain internal support.
Marketing decisions should not be based on internal team members' subjective preferences, such as "I wouldn't click on that." Your team is not your target audience. A culture of A/B testing ideas should always take precedence over personal opinions to avoid a bad marketing environment.
Before launching a major campaign, build a small, informal panel of prospects and customers you can text for quick feedback. This simple, low-cost method provides direct market validation, reduces the risk of failure, and strengthens the business case for new ideas internally.
To avoid constant battles over unproven ideas, proactively allocate 5-10% of the marketing budget to a line item officially called "Marketing Experiments." Frame it to the CFO as a necessary fund for exploring new channels before current ones tap out and for seizing unforeseen opportunities.
To get C-suite buy-in for long-term brand investment, marketers should run small, ring-fenced test campaigns. By isolating a market segment and layering brand tactics on top of demand generation, you can demonstrably prove superior growth compared to a control group, de-risking a larger investment.
Marketing decisions should be driven by testing and data, not by the subjective opinions of internal stakeholders. The phrase "I wouldn't click on that" is a red flag for a poor marketing environment that lacks a culture of experimentation because you are not your audience.
Beyond testing hypotheses, real-world experiments serve a crucial social function: reducing employee fear of change. By co-designing experiments with skeptics to test their specific assumptions, innovation teams can quell fears with data, turning organizational resistance into buy-in.
Don't censor ideas early. The path to innovative marketing is generating a high volume of unconventional, even "bad," ideas. Most will fail, but the one or two that succeed can become massive multipliers for your brand, often requiring you to ask for forgiveness, not permission.
Rather than using formal focus groups, Float validated its bold billboard concepts by involving a small group of existing, friendly customers in the creative process. This provided crucial feedback and built conviction without incurring significant extra cost or time.
To ensure continuous experimentation, Coastline's marketing head allocates a specific "failure budget" for high-risk initiatives. The philosophy is that most experiments won't work, but the few that do will generate enough value to cover all losses and open up crucial new marketing channels.
