Employee Stock Ownership Plans (ESOPs) are limited in impact. Their structure as retirement accounts prevents immediate wealth creation, and their financial requirements are too stringent for most companies, especially startups, effectively excluding 90% of the economy.
The most powerful incentive for increasing employee ownership is to make founder exits to their employees tax-free. This aligns financial self-interest with a social good, making it more profitable for a founder to sell to their team than to private equity.
A founder who hoped to one day sell his company to employees was advised to start now. Implementing an Employee Stock Ownership Plan (ESOP) early aligns the team with the long-term mission, shares the burdens of entrepreneurship, and builds a sustainable, purpose-driven culture from the beginning.
Granting stock options is only half the battle. To make equity a powerful motivator, leaders must constantly communicate a clear and believable narrative for a future liquidity event, such as an acquisition. This vision is what transforms paper ownership into a tangible and valuable incentive in the minds of employees.
Regulations like the 'Accredited Investor' rule, originally designed to shield small investors from risky ventures, are now perceived as gatekeeping. Retail investors argue these rules don't protect them but instead protect the elite's exclusive access to high-growth, wealth-generating opportunities.
The trend of allowing employees to sell shares in secondary transactions before investors get liquidity is a problem. Lior Susan argues this creates a fundamental misalignment, as historically, employees and investors realized returns at the same time. The system needs rethinking for long-duration private companies.
Vested works directly with employees because startups find small, one-off secondary transactions burdensome due to legal fees and cap table complexity. However, this dynamic inverts at scale. Once Vested facilitates millions in transactions for a single company's stock, the startup has a strong incentive to partner on a formal liquidity program.
A business transitions from a founder-dependent "practice" to a scalable "enterprise" only when the founder shares wealth and recognition. Failing to provide equity and public credit prevents attracting and retaining the talent needed for growth, as top performers will leave to become owners themselves.
Gifting non-performance-based shares to all employees doesn't foster an 'owner mindset.' True ownership thinking is better cultivated through incentives tied to specific, controllable outcomes, like targeted cash bonuses. Standard equity compensation often just becomes another part of the salary package, disconnected from individual impact.
Stock options and equity are the primary drivers of wealth for employees, not salary. Unlike salary, which is taxed annually, equity value grows unimpaired by taxes until it's sold. This tax-deferred status allows for faster, unimpeded compounding over time.
The number of founders taking secondary liquidity after their seed round is twice as high as the 2021 peak. While this de-risks the journey for founders, there is almost no parallel liquidity offered to early employees, creating a growing divide in early-stage risk and reward.