In an era of infinite replicability, startups have two viable paths. They can either operate in stealth with a non-obvious, defensible insight ('a secret incantation'), or tackle an obvious problem and win by completely owning the public narrative. The middle ground is no longer viable.
With AI commoditizing technology, the sustainable advantage for startups is the speed and discipline of their experimentation. Founders who leverage AI to operate 10x faster will outcompete those with static tech advantages, as execution velocity is far harder to replicate than a feature.
During a major technology shift like AI, the most valuable initial opportunities are often the simplest. Founders should resist solving complex problems immediately and instead focus on the "low-hanging fruit." Defensibility can be built later, after capitalizing on the obvious, easy wins.
Previously, startups had years before incumbents copied their innovations. With AI coding assistants, incumbents can now replicate features in weeks, not years. This intensifies the battle, making a startup's ability to rapidly acquire distribution its most vital competitive advantage for survival.
AI lowers the barrier to entry, flooding the market with "whiteboard founded" companies tackling low-hanging fruit. This creates a highly competitive, consensus-driven environment that is the opposite of a "good quest." The real challenge is finding meaningful problems.
The pace of AI-driven innovation has accelerated so dramatically that marginal improvements are quickly rendered obsolete. Founders must pursue ideas that offer an order-of-magnitude change to their industry, as anything less will be overtaken by the next wave of technology.
The current trend toward closed, proprietary AI systems is a misguided and ultimately ineffective strategy. Ideas and talent circulate regardless of corporate walls. True, defensible innovation is fostered by openness and the rapid exchange of research, not by secrecy.
The core conflict is whether a startup can achieve mass distribution before the incumbent can replicate its core innovation. Historically, incumbents have an advantage because they eventually catch up on technology. AI may accelerate this, making a startup's unique and rapid path to acquiring customers more critical than ever.
AI tools drastically reduce the time and expertise needed to enter new domains. This allows startups to pivot their entire company quickly to capitalize on shifting investor sentiment and market narratives, making them more agile in a hype-driven environment where narrative alignment attracts capital.
Investors obsess over moats, but in a rapidly changing AI landscape, a startup's ability to quickly build and ship products that unlock latent demand is a more reliable predictor of success than any theoretical defensibility.
The mantra 'ideas are cheap' fails in the current AI paradigm. With 'scaling' as the dominant execution strategy, the industry has more companies than novel ideas. This makes truly new concepts, not just execution, the scarcest resource and the primary bottleneck for breakthrough progress.