In variations of Stanley Milgram's obedience experiments, the presence of nonconformists, or "principled deviants," dramatically reduced the group's willingness to inflict harm. These outsiders model ethical behavior, reining in the cruelty of others and guiding the group toward a better moral outcome.
Related Insights
For a controversial strategic shift, a co-founder's "moral authority" is invaluable. They can absorb the risk of looking foolish and give up their responsibilities ("Legos") to spearhead a new initiative. This allows them to champion a new direction with a level of credibility that can overcome internal skepticism.
To get a group to accept unconventional ideas, first conform to its established values to build trust. This earns you "idiosyncrasy credits," which you can later "spend" on deviating from the norm without being rejected. This 'conform, then innovate' strategy was used by The Beatles to gain mainstream acceptance before experimenting.
The "lone hero" is a myth; bravery is supported by a network. Courageous individuals actively seek help, relying on four distinct categories of support: moral ("I've got your back"), informational ("here's what you need to know"), resource-based, and appraisal-based feedback.
Contrary to pop psychology, guilt can be a powerful motivator. Guilt makes you feel "I did a bad thing," prompting amends. Shame, however, makes you feel "I am a bad person," leading to withdrawal or aggression. A healthy dose of guilt can fuel moral ambition.
When a norm is violated publicly, it threatens the common knowledge that the norm exists and is enforced. The resulting public punishment, like a digital-age pillory, isn't just about the transgressor; it's a signal to the entire community that the norm is still in effect, thereby restoring common knowledge.
Research on WWII resistance heroes found that a key predictive factor for taking life-threatening risks was simply being asked to help. This suggests that moral action is often a response to a direct social request within a community, rather than a pre-existing personality trait. Proactive asking is a catalyst for courage.
Anxiety is not always a pathology but can be a purposeful signal. A study on chimps showed that removing the most sensitive, anxious members led to the entire group's demise, as they were the advance warning system for dangers. This reframes anxiety as a crucial societal function.
Morality is not a static trait you possess but a state you achieve through action. Engaging in pro-social behavior shapes your identity as a moral person, creating a virtuous cycle where action precedes and builds character, which can then inspire others.
Instead of hard-coding brittle moral rules, a more robust alignment approach is to build AIs that can learn to 'care'. This 'organic alignment' emerges from relationships and valuing others, similar to how a child is raised. The goal is to create a good teammate that acts well because it wants to, not because it is forced to.
Shaka Senghor's experience leading a prison gang provides powerful lessons in building culture in a zero-trust environment. He instituted simple, powerful rules: making everyone eat together to build rapport and enforcing a strict code of being 'good to your word,' not just internally but also externally. This created a foundation of trust where none existed.
