Research on WWII resistance heroes found that a key predictive factor for taking life-threatening risks was simply being asked to help. This suggests that moral action is often a response to a direct social request within a community, rather than a pre-existing personality trait. Proactive asking is a catalyst for courage.
Related Insights
Author John Grisham, a longtime death penalty supporter, had a complete change of heart after a prison chaplain asked, "Do you think Jesus will approve of what we do here?" This shows that a well-posed, self-reflective question can be far more persuasive than a direct confrontation, as it bypasses defensiveness.
Instead of trying to convince people of the importance of vulnerability, first have them identify their core values. They will naturally conclude that living up to those values (e.g., courage, excellence) requires them to embrace the uncertainty and risk inherent in vulnerability.
The "lone hero" is a myth; bravery is supported by a network. Courageous individuals actively seek help, relying on four distinct categories of support: moral ("I've got your back"), informational ("here's what you need to know"), resource-based, and appraisal-based feedback.
Contrary to pop psychology, guilt can be a powerful motivator. Guilt makes you feel "I did a bad thing," prompting amends. Shame, however, makes you feel "I am a bad person," leading to withdrawal or aggression. A healthy dose of guilt can fuel moral ambition.
In variations of Stanley Milgram's obedience experiments, the presence of nonconformists, or "principled deviants," dramatically reduced the group's willingness to inflict harm. These outsiders model ethical behavior, reining in the cruelty of others and guiding the group toward a better moral outcome.
People often fail to act not because they fear negative consequences (cowardice), but because they believe their actions won't have a positive impact (futility). Recognizing this distinction is critical; overcoming futility requires demonstrating that change is possible, which is different from mitigating risk.
Drawing inspiration from Antarctic explorer Ernest Shackleton, true optimism isn't a passive belief that things will work out. It's an active, courageous choice. In dire situations, a leader's decision to be optimistic is a strategic tool essential for survival and success.
Contrary to common belief, feeling fear is not what prevents leaders from being courageous. The real barrier is the defensive "armor"—behaviors like micromanagement or feigned intensity—that leaders adopt when afraid. The path to courage involves identifying and shedding this armor, not eliminating fear.
Morality is not a static trait you possess but a state you achieve through action. Engaging in pro-social behavior shapes your identity as a moral person, creating a virtuous cycle where action precedes and builds character, which can then inspire others.
Courage isn't the absence of fear but the decision to act despite it. This reframes bravery from a fixed personality characteristic to a skill that can be developed by choosing to lean into fear and not let it dictate actions.