Shoppers often approach indulgent categories with "healthy goggles," initially seeking better-for-you items. By leading with low-fat or healthy options at the front of an aisle, retailers can increase engagement and foot traffic. Once in the aisle, a significant number of these shoppers then "trade up" to the full-fat versions they originally planned to avoid.

Related Insights

The Diet vs. Zero soda battle demonstrates that for quick, everyday purchases, consumers rely on surface-level cues. The branding and associated identity ("scarcity" vs "wellness") drive decisions more than the product's actual composition, which is often nearly identical. The label effectively becomes the product.

In a study, subtle gray tape lines on a gray carpet—consciously unnoticed by shoppers—steered 18% of them into a target aisle, up from just 4% before. This shows that retailers can use almost invisible environmental cues to powerfully manipulate shopper behavior and store pathing without their awareness.

To encourage better choices, emphasize immediate, tangible rewards over long-term, abstract goals. A Stanford study found diners chose more vegetables when labeled with delicious descriptions ("sizzling Szechuan green beans") versus health-focused ones ("nutritious green beans"). This works with the brain's value system, which prioritizes immediate gratification.

A classic study found placing beer next to diapers boosted sales of both by targeting men on a specific chore. This 'mission-based' merchandising is more effective than rigid category management (e.g., all drinks together), but internal store politics and siloed departments often prevent these shopper-friendly groupings.

People gravitate toward the middle option when given three choices, a bias known as extremeness aversion. To sell more of a specific product, frame it as the middle choice by introducing a more expensive, super-premium 'decoy' option. Its role is not to sell, but to make the target option look like a reasonable compromise.

This is "present bias." In an experiment, 82% of people chose a chocolate bar for immediate consumption, but this dropped to 51% when choosing a snack for the following week. To sell healthy products, target consumers when they are planning for the future (e.g., online grocery shopping), not when they are about to eat.

Consumers are trained by food packaging to look for simple, bold 'macros' (e.g., '7g Protein,' 'Gluten-Free'). Applying this concept to non-food items by clearly stating key attributes ('Chemical-Free,' 'Plant-Based') on the packaging can rapidly educate consumers at the point of purchase and differentiate the product.

In a study, a faint chocolate smell was pumped into a store. While none of the 105 shoppers interviewed afterward consciously noticed the scent, the featured chocolate brand's share jumped by 41%. This demonstrates that subconscious sensory cues can bypass rational thought and directly influence purchasing decisions.

By introducing a third, strategically priced but less appealing option (the "decoy"), you can manipulate how customers perceive value. A medium popcorn priced close to the large makes the large seem like a much better deal. This proves that value is relative and can be shaped by deliberate choice architecture.

A decoy offer is a strategically priced option designed to be ignored. Its purpose is to make your primary, more expensive offer seem more attractive and reasonably priced in comparison. This psychological trick shifts customer preference towards higher-ticket items, increasing average order value.