Get your free personalized podcast brief

We scan new podcasts and send you the top 5 insights daily.

Top literary agent Suzanne Gluck rejects the idea that a bestseller can be architected. When authors ask for a formula for success, she tells them the only chance they have is to write the book they are truly passionate about. Authenticity is a prerequisite that cannot be faked or engineered.

Related Insights

Success in publishing can become a creative trap. Publishers often reject new projects from their bestselling authors if they deviate from an established genre. This risk-averse behavior pigeonholes proven talent and stifles their creative evolution, forcing them to stick to what's safe.

Competing to be 'the best' is a crowded, zero-sum game. A superior strategy is to find a niche where you can be the 'only' one doing what you do. Pursue the ideas that only you appreciate, because that is where you will face no competition and can create your most authentic and valuable work.

Publishers often reject projects from their own successful authors if they deviate from a proven genre. This 'stay in your lane' mentality prioritizes predictable revenue over an author's creative evolution, which can be psychologically damaging and lead to great works never being created.

Don't let the fear that "it's all been said before" stop you from creating. While the facts or tips you share may exist elsewhere, your personal story, experiences, and perspective do not. Your unique lens is your value proposition, allowing you to connect with an audience that needs to hear it from you.

To create a truly extraordinary product, you must temporarily suspend traditional ROI calculations. Author Paul Millerd intentionally ignored his 'MBA brain' to build the 'sexiest book,' prioritizing creative excellence over immediate financial justification, betting that quality would pay off long-term.

Storytelling frameworks are useless without substance. The foundation of a compelling narrative is knowing more about your industry's core problem than anyone else. The goal isn't to master abstract techniques but to develop a deep, unique perspective that you feel compelled to share. The true test: could you write a book on your category?

*Freakonomics* co-author Steve Levitt advises against writing a book if the goal is fame or readership, as the odds are incredibly low. He suggests pursuing it only if the creative process itself is the reward, and you'd be happy even if no one reads it. This filters for intrinsic motivation.

The quest for a completely new idea is futile because they've all been done. Instead, focus on expressing your unique self—your vibe, energy, and perspective. That is the only true originality and what ultimately attracts an audience.

Instead of contorting to fit a market, build something that is 'you pushed out.' The most resonant products are often a natural extension of the founder's obsessions and personality. This authenticity makes the work feel effortless and creates a product that clicks with a specific audience.

Morgan Housel's massively successful book, *The Psychology of Money*, was rejected by all US publishers because its unconventional format—19 disconnected essays—was the opposite of what they wanted. This shows that to achieve an outlier result, you often need an oddball idea that breaks established rules.