The stress hormone cortisol, elevated when an employee feels they don't belong, directly interferes with the hippocampus. This brain region is responsible for memory formation, explaining why even top performers struggle to learn and adapt when onboarded into a "fitting in" culture.
Related Insights
The pressure to conform to a dominant culture ("culture fit") depletes employees' energy. This emotional labor, a "conformity tax," becomes too costly for high-performers, causing them to leave despite high engagement scores, because the cost of fitting in becomes too high.
Neuroscience research shows social exclusion activates the same neural regions as physical pain. This triggers a chronic stress response (cortisol elevation) that shuts down the prefrontal cortex, crippling employees' capacity for creativity, critical thinking, and problem-solving.
In new environments, especially for underrepresented groups, the worry of not belonging acts as a lens. A small, ambiguous event like not being copied on an email is interpreted as confirmation of being an outsider, fueling a cycle of withdrawal.
Stress puts the brain in a high-alert, incoherent state where different regions fire out of order. This mental "static" prevents you from creating a strong, clear intention, effectively blocking your ability to attract desired outcomes and making your brain worse over time.
A company with 78% engagement scores was hemorrhaging high-potential talent. Exit interviews revealed the cause: employees were engaged in their work but were exhausted from trying to "fit in." This shows that engagement and belonging are not the same and must be measured independently.
John Kaplan shares a hard-learned lesson: people who best integrate into new cultures first learn to "be the same" before showcasing their unique differences. Trying to impose your old ways or stand out immediately can alienate you from the team you're trying to join.
Early stress over-activates the amygdala (the brain's stress 'on' switch) while stunting the hippocampus (the 'off' switch). This creates a neurological imbalance of 'all gas, no brakes,' resulting in a state of hypervigilance and dysregulation that is often diagnosed as ADHD.
Even with good pay, employees feel stuck when their primal needs to belong and matter are unmet. The brain interprets this as a survival threat, triggering a stress response, cognitive dissonance, and disengagement.
When stressed, your brain prioritizes immediate protection over long-term strategic thinking, creativity, and leadership. This leads to avoiding risks, rejection, and visibility—the very things necessary for career advancement. Your internal state, not your resume, is the primary bottleneck for success.
When employees feel excluded, the consequence isn't just passive disengagement. It can breed resentment that leads them to withhold crucial ideas, watch things fail without intervening, or even actively work against the organization's interests. Exclusion creates a tangible cost and risk.
