Substack's founder wasn't trying to start a company. He was on sabbatical, writing an essay to articulate his frustrations with the digital media economy. This deep thinking on the core problem became the foundation for the business, prioritizing a strong thesis over a formal plan.

Related Insights

While a formal plan is a useful artifact, the real benefit comes from the strategic thinking required to create it. The process of planning forces founders to clarify their 'why,' define their ideal customer, and strategize their market approach. This mental exercise is more valuable than the static document itself.

Many founders start companies simply because they want the title, not because they are obsessed with a mission. This is a critical mistake, as only a deep, personal passion for a problem can sustain a founder through the inevitable hardships of building a startup.

Instead of chasing trends or pivoting every few weeks, founders should focus on a singular mission that stems from their unique expertise and conviction. This approach builds durable, meaningful companies rather than simply chasing valuations.

If you don't have an industry or idea, don't start with product brainstorming. Start by identifying groups of people you'd genuinely enjoy serving. The foundation of a sustainable business is a founder's deep connection to their customer, which provides motivation to solve their problems.

In school or corporate jobs, the 'rules for success' are provided. Founders enter a world with no such rubric and often fail because they don't consciously develop their own theory of how the world works, instead defaulting to shallow, unexamined beliefs about what founders 'should' do.

Instead of searching for a market to serve, founders should solve a problem they personally experience. This "bottom-up" approach guarantees product-market fit for at least one person—the founder—providing a solid foundation to build upon and avoiding the common failure of abstract, top-down market analysis.

The most potent business ideas are discovered, not forced. They arise naturally from being an active participant in a niche community and experiencing its problems firsthand. Instead of searching for 'an idea,' immerse yourself in a passion; the right opportunity will present itself.

To identify non-consensus ideas, analyze the founder's motivation. A founder with a deep, personal reason for starting their company is more likely on a unique path. Conversely, founders who "whiteboarded" their way to an idea are often chasing mimetic, competitive trends.

The most enduring companies, like Facebook and Google, began with founders solving a problem they personally experienced. Trying to logically deduce a mission from market reports lacks the authenticity and passion required to build something great. The best ideas are organic, not analytical.

A founder deep in the idea maze can articulate not just their current path, but also the alternatives they considered and why they were rejected. This demonstrates a profound understanding of their domain and problem space.