Echoing Warren Buffett, investor Mike Schrepper advises that market dynamics—whether it's growing, shrinking, or has concentrated buyers—are the dominant factor in a company's success. Even an exceptional entrepreneur cannot overcome a fundamentally bad market, whose reputation will ultimately prevail over the founder's talent.
Related Insights
Focusing only on trendy sectors leads to intense competition where the vast majority of startups fail. True opportunity lies in contrarian ideas that others overlook or dismiss, as these markets have fewer competitors.
Entrepreneurs who thrived during past downturns (like 2008) often become complacent. With higher overhead and a more comfortable lifestyle, they are less willing to do the hard, uncomfortable work required to win in a new down market, creating an opportunity for hungrier competitors.
Many LPs focus solely on backing the 'best people.' However, a manager's chosen strategy and market (the 'neighborhood') is a more critical determinant of success. A brilliant manager playing a difficult game may underperform a good manager in a structurally advantaged area.
A founder's success is more dependent on the product's intrinsic value than their operational skills. The best marketer cannot overcome the headwind of a mediocre product that doesn't deserve to be on the shelf. A great product creates a natural tailwind, making growth significantly easier and attracting opportunities.
When evaluating investments, Danny Meyer prioritizes leadership quality over the initial concept. He believes a strong leader can pivot and improve a mediocre idea, whereas even a brilliant concept is doomed to fail under poor leadership. This highlights the primacy of execution over ideation for investors.
Investors often reject ideas in markets where previous companies failed, a bias they call "scar tissue." This creates an opportunity for founders who can identify a key change—like new AI technology or shifting consumer behavior—that makes a previously impossible idea now viable.
Market dynamics are not static. What was once a 'wave'—a new, urgent problem for everyone—can evolve into a series of 'dams' and eventually a stable 'river.' A common mistake is to build for the hype of a wave after it has crested, by which point it no longer provides the same opportunity for explosive growth.
A profitable business that requires the founder's constant involvement is just a high-paying job, not a valuable asset. Enterprise value, which makes a business sellable, is only created when systems and employees can generate profit independently of the founder's direct labor.
A great founder cannot salvage a dead market. Success is a multiplication of founder skill, product viability, and market hunger. If any of these factors, especially the market, scores near zero, the total outcome will be near zero, regardless of how strong the other components are.
In a hyper-growth market where demand is at an all-time high, it's easy to mistake a favorable environment for individual skill. This powerful 'current' can hide significant operational flaws, which only become apparent when the market inevitably shifts, as seen in the ZIRP era.
