Undersecretary Sarah Rogers describes the internet's evolution from a free, anonymous space to a sanitized "shopping mall." This "gentrification," driven by increased commerce and family use, has eroded the chaotic freedom that once fostered creativity and open expression.
Podcast host Ben Smith posits that there was an asymmetry in media consumption, with conservatives closely following left-leaning outlets like Gawker. This gave them deep insights into their ideological opponents, while many on the left remained unaware of the right's media ecosystem.
Undersecretary Rogers warns against "safetyist" regulatory models for AI. She argues that attempting to code models to never produce offensive or edgy content fetters them, reduces their creative and useful capacity, and ultimately makes them less competitive globally, particularly against China.
Undersecretary Rogers explains that the US approach to speech policy varies by country. Saudi Arabia, despite its restrictions, is seen as liberalizing and is encouraged. In contrast, Europe is viewed as having a negative trajectory, making it a higher-priority target for US diplomatic pressure.
Rogers argues that Gawker's aesthetic of "snark" and its click-driven, short-form polemical model served as a petri dish. When this model merged with the social justice focus of young journalists in the Obama era, it created the dominant "woke" media culture.
US Undersecretary Rogers uses the metaphor of "regulatory gravity" to describe how EU rules, like the Digital Services Act, compel global compliance. Companies conform to EU standards even in markets like the UK, demonstrating a de facto extraterritorial reach that impacts global commerce and policy.
A US Diplomat argues that laws like the EU's DSA and the UK's Online Safety Act create a chilling effect. By imposing vague obligations with massive fines, they push risk-averse corporations to censor content excessively, leading to ridiculous outcomes like parliamentary speeches being blocked.
Fearing Gawker's notoriously harsh commenters would dissect her wedding, Sarah Rogers created multiple anonymous accounts. She planned to use these "sock puppets" to post positive comments and defend herself, viewing it as a personal public diplomacy tactic to manage a hostile information environment.
When challenged on Elon Musk's tweet endorsing "white solidarity," Undersecretary Rogers reframes the sentiment. She suggests it stems from his South African background, where some white people in isolated settlements may see solidarity as necessary for survival, rather than as an expression of American-style racism.