A significant stagnation in job growth since May coincides with both new tariff implementations (reducing labor demand) and stricter immigration policies (constraining labor supply). This combination has created a powerful dual shock that has effectively halted job creation in the US economy.

An astonishing 97.3% of all private sector job gains in 2025 occurred within the healthcare industry. This extreme concentration highlights a narrow and potentially fragile labor market, with net job losses seen across the private sector when healthcare is excluded.

The current labor market is in a state of paralysis, described as a "deer in the headlights" moment. Businesses, facing extreme uncertainty from tariffs and policy shifts, have frozen both hiring and layoffs. This creates a stagnant, low-dynamism environment where both employers and employees are cautiously waiting.

State-level unemployment insurance data, available during the government shutdown, shows a distinct trend. Initial claims are low (companies aren't laying people off), but continuing claims are elevated (it's hard for the unemployed to find new jobs), confirming a stagnant labor market.

The combination of solid GDP growth and weaker job creation is not necessarily a warning sign, but a structural shift. With productivity growth rebounding to its 2% historical average and labor supply constrained by lower immigration, the economy can grow robustly without adding as many jobs as in the past.

Instead of a single, declared recession, various private sectors experienced individual downturns at different times since 2022. This out-of-consensus view suggests the economic cycle has already bottomed, explaining why stocks have rallied strongly since what the speaker calls 'Liberation Day' in April.

Mastercard's Chief Economist argues the labor market is in balance, not collapsing. A slowdown from 175k to ~70k jobs/month is a necessary correction from an unsustainable, post-pandemic surge. With both labor demand (hiring) and supply decreasing, key metrics like the unemployment rate remain stable, indicating equilibrium rather than decline.

By averaging data from ADP and Reveglio Labs, two key private sector sources, economists forecast that official Bureau of Labor Statistics (BLS) job growth figures for October and November will likely be close to zero. This points to a significant slowdown and stagnation in the labor market.

In 2025, economic forecasts were incredibly accurate on monthly job growth (predicting 124K vs. an actual 125K) but significantly missed the stock market's performance, predicting a 10% gain versus the actual 15%. This highlights the disparity in predictability between fundamental economic data and sentiment-driven financial markets.