In Canada's supply-managed dairy system, farmers must own a quota to sell milk. This government-issued right has become so valuable that it is typically worth more than the farm's land, cows, and equipment combined. This unique economic structure is a core driver of trade tensions with the U.S.
Related Insights
The US has lost over half its cattle operations in a generation, and the average rancher is now over 58. A long-term "cost-price squeeze" has made the profession financially unattractive, leading families to encourage their children to pursue other careers and threatening the industry's future labor supply.
While the US exports less to Canada by volume, its exports (electronics, pharma) have far higher margins and shareholder value multiples than Canadian exports (lumber, oil). Therefore, for every dollar of trade disrupted by tariffs, the US loses significantly more economic value, making the policy self-defeating.
Dairy farms now derive significant income from breeding cows for the beef industry, not just for milk production. Leveraging genetic technologies like genomics and gender-sorted semen allows farmers to strategically produce high-value beef calves, transforming a secondary income source into a major revenue stream.
When trade policies force allies like Canada to find new partners, it's not a temporary shift. They build new infrastructure and relationships that won't be abandoned even if the political climate changes. The trust is broken, making the economic damage long-lasting and difficult to repair.
In 1980, cattle producers received over 60 cents of every consumer dollar spent on beef. Due to market consolidation, this has reversed. By 2021, packers and retailers captured over 60 cents, while producers received less than 40 cents, despite bearing the longest production risk.
Certain "trophy assets," like major league sports teams, defy traditional valuation metrics. Their true worth is determined not by their cash flow, which can be modest, but by their extreme scarcity and the price a private acquirer is willing to pay for the prestige of ownership, as seen in private market transactions.
Geopolitical shifts mean a company's country of origin heavily influences its market access and tariff burdens. This "corporate nationality" creates an uneven playing field, where a business's location can instantly become a massive advantage or liability compared to competitors.
Major corporations are applying the vertical integration model from poultry ("chickenization") to beef. This system controls the supply chain from genetics to retail, aiming to eliminate the competitive cash market and turn independent ranchers into de facto contract growers.
In a functional market, raw material (cattle) and end-product (beef) prices move together. Due to high consolidation in meatpacking, packers can increase consumer beef prices while suppressing prices paid to ranchers, creating an inverse relationship and capturing the spread.
Tariffs on foreign steel don't simply allow buyers to switch to domestic suppliers. A manufacturer of oil industry parts explained that most domestic mills aren't geared for their specific needs or quality requirements (e.g., heat treating). This reveals how tariffs create complex availability and quality challenges, not just simple price increases.