Pouring marketing resources into a "leaky bucket" is inefficient. If customer onboarding is flawed, prioritize fixing it before optimizing top-of-funnel campaigns. The highest leverage is in ensuring activated users convert, not in acquiring more users who will quickly churn.
Related Insights
When a business gets high visibility but low conversions, the impulse is to blame the platform or marketing tactic (the 'sink'). However, the real issue is often the core offering—the product, pricing, or value proposition (the 'well'). People obsess over front-end fixes when the back-end is the actual problem.
GoProposal viewed high-touch, proactive onboarding as part of their acquisition cost. Before a trial user even entered their credit card, the team would manually set up their account with brand assets. This "shock and awe" approach wowed customers and dramatically increased conversion.
Mailtrap invested in creating a streamlined, low-friction onboarding experience, assuming it would significantly boost conversions. The change had almost no impact. They discovered their developer audience valued the product's core utility so much that they were willing to complete extra steps, rendering the simplified UX improvements ineffective for conversion.
Even a seemingly acceptable 4% monthly churn will eventually cap your growth, as acquiring new customers becomes a treadmill to replace lost ones. Reducing churn to 2.5-3% is a more powerful growth lever than finding new marketing channels once you hit a plateau.
ROAS (Return on Ad Spend) is a vanity metric that can mask unprofitable customer acquisition. By focusing on POAS (Profit on Ad Spend), brands are forced to measure the actual profit generated from advertising, linking marketing directly to bottom-line health and avoiding the trap of 'growing broke'.
Instead of focusing solely on conversion rates, measure 'engagement quality'—metrics that signal user confidence, like dwell time, scroll depth, and journey progression. The philosophy is that if you successfully help users understand the content and feel confident, conversions will naturally follow as a positive side effect.
Reacting to churn is a losing battle. The secret is to identify the characteristics of your best customers—those who stay and are happy to pay. Then, channel all marketing and sales resources into acquiring more customers that fit this 'stayer' profile, effectively designing churn out of your funnel.
Every business has a growth ceiling where new customer acquisition is completely offset by churn. No matter how many new customers you add per month, your business will stop growing once churn equals acquisition. Plugging this 'leaky bucket' is more valuable than pouring more water in.
The biggest initial hurdle for a new product isn't getting the first dollar of revenue; it's crossing the chasm from a user trying the product once to becoming a truly engaged, repeat user. This "penny gap of engagement" is the most critical early milestone to overcome for long-term success.
When sales teams hit quotas but customer churn rises, the root cause is a disconnect between sales promises and operational reality. The fix requires aligning sales, marketing, and customer service around a single, unified strategy for the entire customer journey.
