Instead of immediately issuing a statement during the backlash, American Eagle waited nine days. This delay created a vacuum that was filled by other people and media outlets questioning the absurdity of the claims, shifting public sentiment in the brand's favor before they even responded.
Related Insights
The backlash transformed a standard ad campaign into a cultural phenomenon that generated 45 billion impressions. This massive earned media reach dwarfed competitor campaigns, demonstrating that provocative work—even with negative reactions—can deliver far greater ROI than a safe media buy.
Auntie Anne's founder Anne Beiler intentionally shared a damaging personal story on national TV. This preemptive move neutralized the information's power, ensuring future journalists couldn't use it as a "salacious" exposé. This strategy of "taking the air out of the balloon" protects long-term brand reputation by controlling the narrative from the start.
In analyzing a public scandal, Scott Galloway notes that the greatest damage in a crisis typically isn't the initial event but the subsequent "shrapnel": the attempts to cover up, excuse, or avoid accountability. An effective response requires acknowledging the problem, taking responsibility, and overcorrecting.
In a crisis, the instinct is to shout louder and match escalating chaos. True leadership involves 'energetic jujitsu': deliberately slowing down and bringing calmness to the situation. This rare skill is more powerful than simply increasing intensity.
Instead of reacting defensively to negative press, the team reframed the situation as an opportunity. This mindset shift led them to stick to their plan and amplify the campaign's reach by focusing on positive business signals, rather than apologizing or retracting.
The CMO found the barrage of social media comments and unsolicited expert advice to be confusing and frustrating. He made a conscious decision to turn off professional networks like LinkedIn, allowing him to focus on hard data and lead his team without emotional distraction.
In a crisis, the public knows no one has all the answers. Attempting to project absolute certainty backfires. A more effective strategy is "confident humility": transparently sharing information gaps and explaining that plans will evolve as new data emerges, which builds credibility.
While mainstream media covers the high-level controversy of a failed campaign, specialized trade publications dissect the granular, tactical mistakes. For practitioners, this peer review is often more damaging and insightful, as it judges the professional execution and ethical choices made behind the scenes.
Trust can be destroyed in a single day, but rebuilding it is a multi-year process with no shortcuts. The primary driver of recovery is not a PR campaign but a consistent, long-term track record of shipping product and addressing user complaints. There are very few "spikes upward" in regaining brand trust.
During a campaign controversy, the CMO saw conflicting signals: social media outrage versus positive stock performance and sales data. He chose to trust the hard business metrics as the source of truth, giving him the confidence to ignore the noise and hold the line.