Trust can be destroyed in a single day, but rebuilding it is a multi-year process with no shortcuts. The primary driver of recovery is not a PR campaign but a consistent, long-term track record of shipping product and addressing user complaints. There are very few "spikes upward" in regaining brand trust.
Related Insights
To truly change a brand's narrative, marketing's 'talking the talk' is insufficient. The product experience itself must embody the desired story. This 'walking the walk' through the product is the most powerful way to shape core brand perception and make the narrative shareable.
In analyzing a public scandal, Scott Galloway notes that the greatest damage in a crisis typically isn't the initial event but the subsequent "shrapnel": the attempts to cover up, excuse, or avoid accountability. An effective response requires acknowledging the problem, taking responsibility, and overcorrecting.
The Browser Company's pivot required spending the "trust points" they'd built with their team and community. Leaders must be prepared for this painful drawdown and the internal/external backlash, even when they have high conviction in the new direction. It's a necessary but difficult part of a major strategic shift.
During major internal changes (e.g., tech refactoring, price hikes), users can feel neglected. Bending Spoons found that monthly video updates for Evernote were crucial for reassuring the community, demonstrating progress, and putting a human face on the company to directly address concerns.
To evaluate AI's role in building relationships, marketers must look beyond transactional KPIs. Leading indicators of success include sustained engagement, customers volunteering more information, and recommending the experience to others. These metrics quantify brand trust and empathy—proving the brand is earning belief, not just attention.
As return volumes rise, brands that make the process effortless and predictable will earn loyalty that can't be bought. This frictionless experience during a period of high customer anxiety builds a durable competitive moat. Every return also generates compounding data advantages for future forecasting and merchandising, further widening the gap.
Customers and audiences don't trust you because every product is perfect; they trust you because you consistently show up. The identity shift from being someone who creates perfect things to someone who is reliable is crucial. Consistency in shipping and showing up will always outperform sporadic, 'perfect' launches.
When hypergrowth causes you to fail internal stakeholders (like Operations), apologies are insufficient. Rebuild trust by going to the CEO and board *together* with the slighted team to advocate for a drastic roadmap pivot that prioritizes their needs, demonstrating true commitment to their success.
'Do not reply' isn't just poor CX; it's a strategic failure. It represents 'deliberate blindness,' blocking the high-fidelity customer data needed to train AI models. This tells customers you want their money but not their voice, creating a 'brand debt' that catastrophically erodes trust.
For a mature company like Square, the primary marketing challenge is not building awareness but correcting an outdated public perception. Many customers still associate them with their original 'little white reader,' unaware of the full product portfolio, requiring a strategy focused on education and perception shift.
