While the S&P 500's 19% gain since last year seems strong, it significantly lags global performance. An ETF tracking worldwide stock markets is up 42% in the same period, with markets like South Korea and the Eurozone showing even larger returns. This indicates a potential "sell America" trend among global investors.
For the first time in a decade, European equities have broken out of their constantly widening valuation discount range compared to the US. Historically, such breakouts have signaled the beginning of a long-term upward trend where the valuation gap narrows significantly.
Historically, US earnings outgrew the world by 1%. Post-GFC, this widened to 3%. Investors have extrapolated this recent, higher rate as the new normal, pushing the US CAPE ratio to nearly double that of non-US markets. This represents a historically extreme valuation based on a potentially temporary growth advantage.
Contrary to the dominant narrative focused on US tech giants, data shows European banks and a global deep value approach have outperformed the 'Mag 7' over the last one, three, and five years. This highlights the importance of looking beyond popular headlines for actual investment performance.
Contrary to the growth narrative, the MSCI China index returned just 3.4% over the last decade with over 24% volatility. During the same period, the emerging market ex-China index delivered a higher return of 4.8% with significantly lower volatility (17.5%), highlighting structural headwinds in China for investors.
In 2025, US stocks underperformed global peers despite superior earnings growth. Non-US markets saw significant price increases on flat or negative earnings, a divergence that Goldman Sachs Wealth Management believes is unsustainable, reinforcing their long-term US overweight thesis based on earnings fundamentals.
Contrary to the dominant narrative of US market leadership, European equities have actually outperformed their US counterparts when measured in constant currency terms since the last US presidential election. This surprising trend is a fact that most investors may not realize.
American market dominance has been heavily financed by foreign savings. As geopolitics shift, countries like Japan and Germany will likely repatriate that capital to fund domestic priorities like defense and energy, creating a significant, underappreciated headwind for U.S. assets.
Contrary to popular belief, when measured in constant currency, European equities have outperformed their US counterparts since the last US elections. This trend is not widely recognized by investors, setting the stage for a potential re-evaluation of the region.
Despite significant media attention on its strong performance, the American stock market was outperformed by many others globally in 2025. Israel's stock market, for instance, had the best year, challenging the common perception that the US market is the default leader in annual gains.
Morgan Stanley's 2026 outlook suggests a strong US market will create a "slipstream" effect, lifting European equities. This uplift will come from valuation multiple expansion, not strong local earnings, as investors anticipate Europe will eventually benefit from the broadening US economic recovery.