Get your free personalized podcast brief

We scan new podcasts and send you the top 5 insights daily.

A key challenge is defining the platform's role. Is it a self-contained portfolio to be optimized internally, or a flexible infrastructure to access talent and manage cash efficiently for the entire fund? SWIB developed a hybrid model where PMs can 'graduate' to become a standalone line item.

Related Insights

Direct control over a trading platform opens up opportunities for large institutions like SWIB to use other assets strategically. For example, their large long-only index funds can become a source for stock loans to the short-selling PMs on their own platform, creating powerful internal synergies.

Since allocators control the cash in a managed account, the operational risk of a younger firm is mitigated. Diligence becomes faster and more focused on qualitative aspects, like speaking with a PM's former analysts to understand their decision-making and temperament.

Tim Guinness identifies the biggest risk to asset management firms as disintermediation by platforms and wealth managers who can launch their own funds. To secure their future, he believes firms like his must evolve by moving into the platform and wealth management business to own the end-customer relationship.

In a TPA model, diversification is a total-portfolio responsibility. This frees individual teams from needing to diversify within their silo. They can build more concentrated, high-conviction portfolios, as their contribution is assessed at the whole-fund level, where diversification is achieved across different strategies.

Unlike traditional asset allocation where portfolio decisions are jointly owned, TPA clarifies governance. The board sets a risk appetite via a reference portfolio, but management is solely accountable for constructing and managing the actual investment portfolio, making their performance directly and transparently measurable.

The stigma of managed accounts representing managers in dire need of assets has flipped. Now, successful PMs from top firms use them to launch their own businesses with strong, long-term capital partners, indicating positive selection.

Unlike redeeming from a fund, allocators on a managed account platform can meet cash needs by accessing unencumbered cash directly. This provides liquidity without forcing the manager to sell positions, protecting the investment strategy and the relationship.

A pure TPA system can alienate specialists hired for specific asset classes. A hybrid model, where a portion of capital is allocated to traditional buckets, allows organizations to retain deep expertise in areas like private equity while still gaining the benefits of a holistic TPA overlay on the rest.

Council Capital intentionally uses the term 'toolkits' instead of 'playbooks.' This reflects a collaborative philosophy of equipping portfolio companies with tools and resources to solve unique problems, rather than dictating a one-size-fits-all strategy.

The Total Portfolio Approach (TPA) requires a fundamental shift in how an investment organization sees itself. It's not a technical asset allocation change but a cultural transformation that aligns every decision—people, capabilities, risk, and liquidity—with the fund's ultimate goals, moving beyond simple portfolio construction.