In a true market economy, labor shortages are impossible; wages would simply rise to attract workers. The argument that a country needs low-skilled immigrants to fill jobs is often a way to artificially suppress wages for the domestic working class, preventing market forces from correcting the balance.
Related Insights
Beyond its long-term growth benefits, rational immigration policy can be a powerful short-term tool against inflation. By addressing labor shortages in critical sectors like construction, agriculture, and elder care, an increased and targeted immigrant workforce can directly reduce cost pressures on essential goods and services.
A significant stagnation in job growth since May coincides with both new tariff implementations (reducing labor demand) and stricter immigration policies (constraining labor supply). This combination has created a powerful dual shock that has effectively halted job creation in the US economy.
While tariffs affect goods prices, immigration controls are reducing the labor supply, particularly in the service sector. This creates upward wage and price pressure on services, a subtle but significant contributor to overall inflation that is difficult to isolate in real-time data.
While one-third of construction workers are non-native born, restrictive immigration policy's impact is currently muted by a cyclical decline in building. This temporary relief masks a structural labor shortage that will become a major constraint as the market recovers in 2026-2027.
Wage stagnation is not accidental but a result of two concurrent policies. By sending manufacturing jobs overseas and simultaneously bringing in low-wage labor, corporations create a market where domestic workers lose nearly all leverage to demand higher pay for remaining jobs.
America intentionally avoided solving illegal immigration because it serves a crucial economic purpose: providing a flexible, cheap labor force that doesn't draw on social safety nets. This benefits industries and consumers while placing little burden on the state.
The US labor market is stuck in a 'low hire, low fire' mode, preventing a more robust recovery. This stagnation is not from a lack of demand but is directly attributed to the combined effects of restrictive immigration controls and the lingering impact of tariffs, which suppress hiring activity and consumer purchasing power.
Restricting immigration halts a key source of labor for essential sectors like agriculture and construction. This drives up consumer costs and could cut GDP by 4-7%, creating a direct path to higher inflation and slower economic growth.
The restaurant industry, historically reliant on undocumented immigrants, faces a severe labor shortage due to tighter immigration. This has shrunk the pool of experienced cooks, causing the value of remaining documented workers to skyrocket. Wages now average nearly double the local minimum wage.
By shipping millions of jobs overseas, globalism forced American workers to compete with a much larger, cheaper international labor pool. This eliminated employers' need to compete for a finite domestic workforce, leading to wage stagnation. The proposed solution is to bring manufacturing jobs back to the U.S.
