Morgan Stanley posits the U.S. economy experienced a 'rolling recession' where different sectors declined sequentially. This downturn's 'finishing move' was a contraction in government jobs, which paradoxically signaled the end of the broader recession and the beginning of a recovery cycle.

Related Insights

The ratio of leading-to-coincident economic indicators is at historic lows seen only in deep recessions (1982, 2009). However, this may be skewed by the leading indicators' reliance on extremely negative consumer sentiment surveys. This divergence suggests we might be at the bottom of a cycle, not the beginning of a downturn.

A powerful market signal is the "quad count," or the forecasted sequence of economic regimes. A progression from Quad 4 (recession fears) to Quad 3 and then to Quads 2 and 1 creates a powerful contrarian setup. This allows investors to buy assets like small caps when recession probabilities are priced at their highest.

Morgan Stanley identifies a rare divergence between strong U.S. spending data and very weak employment figures. How this tension resolves will determine the global economy's path in 2026, creating either a mild recession or a spending-driven boom. Other major economies like Europe and China are not expected to be sources of major surprises.

While mass firings of federal workers may not significantly alter overall payroll statistics, their real impact is a potential shock to consumer and business confidence. This second-order effect on sentiment is a key underappreciated risk that the market has not fully priced into the US dollar.

Fed Chair Powell highlighted that annual benchmark revisions to labor data could reveal that the U.S. economy is already shedding jobs, contrary to initial reports. This statistical nuance, creating a "curious balance" with a stable unemployment rate, makes the Fed more inclined to cut rates to manage this underlying uncertainty.

A recent White House memo indicates that employees in departments reliant on discretionary funding could be permanently dismissed, unlike typical shutdowns where workers are furloughed and retain jobs. This introduces a new, more severe labor market risk that could negatively impact the dollar.

A sharp, V-shaped rebound in corporate earnings revision breadth is a powerful but uncommon leading indicator. It suggests the private economy is decisively exiting an earnings recession and shifting into an early-cycle recovery, often before traditional economic data confirms the trend.

Including government employment in GDP calculations is a form of double-counting tax revenue that masks the true health of the private sector. A major reduction in federal workers would reveal a startlingly low real growth rate, exposing decades of underlying economic stagnation.

Large, negative revisions to economic data often occur around major economic turning points. This is because companies hit first by a downturn are more likely to delay reporting their data, which makes the initial economic reports appear stronger than reality.

The U.S. economy's only viable solution to its long-term debt and inflation is a "beautiful deleveraging"—a painful but controlled economic downturn. The alternative is delaying and being pushed off the cliff by market forces, resulting in a much more severe and uncontrolled crash.

A 'Government Recession' Can Signal the End of a Broader Economic Downturn | RiffOn